News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by brokencode on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:55PM (#42555952)
Mozilla is almost totally dependent on payments from Google to survive. If Google stops the payments, Mozilla probably goes out of business.

I think it’s pretty clear why they keep on doing this type of side project. They are trying anything they can think of to diversify revenue.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by teruakohatu on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:00PM (#42555981)
> from Google to survive. If Google stops the payments, Mozilla probably goes out of business.

> I think it’s pretty clear why they keep on doing this type of side project.

It’s not clear to me. I agree they would have some problems if Google declined to pay them because the next best offer would be lower.

But the best way to keep these payments, or to increase them, is by making a better browser and giving people a reason to use Firefox. After spinning off Servo I lost the last hope I had.

It seems everyone is stuffing AI summary tools into everything, is this something that will retain users or bring in new users? I doubt it.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by _heimdall on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:31PM (#42556179)
The least cynical view, in my opinion, is that Google is an ad company, which ultimately means they are a data company. They don't need Mozilla to build a better browser, they need Mozilla to increase the amount of user data Google can collect and ad spots Google can sell.

The more cynical view is that Google doesn't care at all about Mozilla because the investment is nothing more than a hedge against regulatory pressure.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by griomnib on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:14PM (#42556346)
A hedge that didn’t pay off despite the Mozilla CEO doing their part at trial and then promptly retiring on a huge pile of GOOG bucks.
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by dralley on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:31PM (#42556175)
Most non-tech "normies", which is to say 95% of the population, barely know what a browser is. They couldn't describe the function of one, or discriminate what makes one better than another. They certainly won't give a crap about Servo, or extremely marginal improvements in page load time (at best).
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by teruakohatu on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:12PM (#42556342)
Given that web browsers are the heaviest application most users are running, and they are running them on low end 10yr old laptops with 8gb of RAM, I think an ultra modern lightweight web browser would be noticeably better.

Web browser crawl on these low end laptops.

This is how Firefox became popular in the first place, by being better.

The “we need an alternative to the “WebKit/blink/chromium” monopoly is what the majority of people will never care about.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by cosmic_cheese on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:32PM (#42556415)
Web slowness has much more to do with sites than with browsers. Where sites have accumulated Everest-sized balls of JavaScript mud, web engines have only become more optimized. If you visit “old web” style pages (Macintosh Garden for example) on old machines with modern browsers there’s no speed problem at all.

In the face of all that JS, there’s only so far a spiffy new browser can improve the situation, aside from maybe drop large chunks of legacy web standards but then you’re breaking large chunks of the web.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by skydhash on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @12:14AM (#42556588)
Most of the new features on the web are corporation driven. The only web site I reluctantly give microphone access is Google Meet and this should have been a desktop app. We have so many layout engines in a browser while layout for both documents and GUI have been solved for decades. Every new feature is just reinventing the wheel to solve a non problem.
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by freetonik on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @12:56AM (#42556752)
From my experience observing and interacting with “normal” non-tech users, slowness of apps and long loading times are simply ignored. I would think “how the hell can you live like that?!”, and they would at best say “yeah it’s kinda slow”.
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by rendaw on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:40PM (#42556455)
They also wouldn't use Firefox - they'd use Chrome, Edge, or (more likely) Chrome/Safari mobile. People who use Firefox are already tech people or the family of.
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by soulofmischief on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:25PM (#42556136)
Browsers are a means to an end for other major providers excluding for Opera. They can be loss leaders even, as long as they do their job of steering users towards proprietary ecosystems
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by brokencode on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @04:01PM (#42561795)
You bring up a great example. Mozilla poured tons of resources and had very smart people working on Rust, Servo, and related tech projects to improve Firefox. Where was the surge of market share?

We’re at a point where the core functionality of browsers is very mature. It’s unlikely that any amount of investment will produce a browser that is significantly faster at things like JS execution or rendering compared to Chrome.

So alternative browsers add things like better ad blockers, more privacy protections, or maybe LLM summaries to enhance the core browser experience instead.

Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by skeeter2020 on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:27PM (#42556148)
For some of the stated reasons this seems like a terrible way to diversify and add any revenue. What if they take a page from Silicon Valley? If the US Government makes Hooli, I mean Google, divest Chrome could Mozilla acquire it?
Re:Orbit. Mozilla's AI Assistant for Firefox by brokencode on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @04:28PM (#42561969)
That would give Mozilla $20B of debt and an even bigger dependence on Google for payments, at least initially.

Though in the long term, maybe they could use the market share to make money in other ways.

But if they can’t manage to make money in other ways with Firefox, I’m not sure that they’d be able to do it with Chrome either.