As someone who has built and deployed a cross-platform app on AIR, I must respectfully disagree.
AIR doesn't give you access to a lot of native features of smartphones. As the most glaring oversight, I had to do some deep hacking on AIR's launcher to support in-app billing. Phonegap's extensible plugin approach looks a lot easier.
And the user experience is different, too. After months of work, my first review rolled in: one star, and said simply, "AIR crap." And no wonder. Without so much as the ability to display my own splashscreen beforehand, AIR simply asks the user, "Hi, would you like to do a 16 MB download to support this app that you don't even know what it does yet?" I've had my friends give me funny looks at that prompt. "When I'm done looking at this, I can delete that, right?" one of them asked.
If you do Phonegap -- or heck, even just raw HTML5 -- I'm not sure your users even need to know.
Phonegap gets to bundle the platform because their hello world is only 300k. I really don't think AIR could get away with that.
But I agree, the user experience might be better if that was an option.
Nonetheless, between a heavyweight and power-hungry executable, an expensive editor, and a scripting language and library for which the most complimentary term I have is "quirky", I really don't understand how AIR is considered even a serious contender in the space of cross-platform . . . platforms. Let alone the best.
Even their web services like Adobe LiveCycle have been a breeze to use and were able to accomplish real-time collaboration in multiple Flash project with maybe 100 lines of total code. That's powerful.
Flash, esp. after MXML is an amazing platform for development but it is dismissed a lot by people who have never used it or maybe got biased using a poorly created end-product.
P.S. It's similar to how I used to think that Java was the worst programming language owning to regular "null pointer exceptions" and "slow loading" applets which I now clearly understand are not the fault of the language but the people who used it (esp after seeing awesome projects like Eclipse). Same goes for Flash. There are some super amazing stuff done in Flash, which is ultra fast, ultra robust and beats the pants down of any HTML5 application.
It's one of those things that seems nifty from a developer convenience point-of-view but results in poor user experience - pretty much every Flex app I've seen that made heavy use of bindings ran horribly slowly.
[0] http://www.w3.org/TR/css3-flexbox/
[1] http://caniuse.com/flexbox
[2] http://flexiejs.com/ (try the "Play with it" link)
In spite of the massive hype differential vs. appcelerator and phonegap, Adobe's AIR is one of the best ways to build & deploy cross-platform mobile apps right now. That's flash, that's mobile, and it's a far cry from "admitting defeat".
Flash on the desktop browser is increasingly limited to a small set of niche uses. Flash inside a mobile browser was never a good idea, and it's dying. The decline of those two specific use cases should not be construed as a general death of the flash platform.