News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ben_w on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:15PM (#42524527)
Are you sure?

The average brown rat may use only 60 kcal per day, but the maximum firing rate of biological neurons is about 100-1000 Hz rather than the A100 clock speed of about 1.5 GHz*, so the silicon gets through the same data set something like 1.5e6-1.5e7 times faster than a rat could.

Scaling up to account for the speed difference, the rat starts looking comparable to a 9e7 - 9e8 kcal/day, or 4.4 to 44 megawatts, computer.

* and the transistors within the A100 are themselves much faster, because clock speed is ~ how long it takes for all chained transistors to flip in the most complex single-clock-cycle operation

Also I'm not totally confident about my comparison because I don't know how wide the data path is, how many different simultaneous inputs a rat or a transformer learns from

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by legacynl on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:55PM (#42524921)
That's a stupid analogy because you're comparing a brainprocess to a full animal.

Only a small part of that 60kcal is used for learning, and for that same 60 kcal you get an actual physical being that is able to procreate, eat, do things and fend for and maintain itself.

Also you cannot compare neuron firing rates with clockspeed. Afaik each neuron in a ml-model can have code that takes several clock cycles to complete.

Also an neuron in ml is just a weighted value, a biological neuron does much more than that. For example neurons communicate using neuro transmitters as well as using voltage potentials. The actual date rate of biological neurons is therfore much higher and complex.

Basically your analogy is false because your napkin-math basically forgets that the rat is an actual biological rat and not something as neatly defined as a computer chip

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ben_w on Friday December 27, 2024 @02:09PM (#42525074)
> Also an neuron in ml is just a weighted value, a biological neuron does much more than that. For example neurons communicate using neuro transmitters as well as using voltage potentials. The actual date rate of biological neurons is therfore much higher and complex.

The conclusion does not follow from the premise. The observed maximum rate of the inter-neuron communication is important, the mechanism is not.

> Also you cannot compare neuron firing rates with clockspeed. Afaik each neuron in a ml-model can have code that takes several clock cycles to complete.

Depends how you're doing it.

Jupyter notebook? Python in general? Sure.

A100s etc., not so much — those are specialist systems designed for this task:

"""1024 dense FP16/FP32 FMA operations per clock""" - https://images.nvidia.com/aem-dam/en-zz/Solutions/data-cente...

"FMA" meaning "fused multiply-add". It's the unit that matters for synapse-equivalents.

(Even that doesn't mean they're perfect fits: IMO a "perfect fit" would likely be using transistors as analog rather than digital elements, and then you get to run them at the native transistor speed of ~100 GHz or so and don't worry too much about how many bits you need to represent the now-analog weights and biases, but that's one of those things which is easy to say from a comfortable armchair and very hard to turn into silicon).

> Basically your analogy is false because your napkin-math basically forgets that the rat is an actual biological rat and not something as neatly defined as a computer chip

Any of those biological functions that don't correspond to intelligence, make the comparison more extreme in favour of the computer.

This is, after all, a question of their mere intelligence, not how well LLMs (or indeed any AI) do or don't function as von Neumann replicators, which is where things like "procreate, eat, do things and fend for and maintain itself" would actually matter.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by imtringued on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:42AM (#42530659)
You're so deep into this nonsense I don't think anything I could possibly say to you would change your mind, so I'll try something different.

Have you thought about stepping back from all of this for a few days and notice that you are wasting your time with these arguments? It doesn't matter how fast you can calculate a dot product or evaluate an activation function if the weights in question do not change.

NNs as of right now are the equivalent of a brain scan. You can simulate how that brain scan would answer a question, but the moment you close the Q and A session, you will have to start from scratch. Making higher resolution brain scans may help you get more precise answers to more questions, but it will never change the questions that it can answer after you have made the brain scan.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ben_w on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:45AM (#42531004)
> Have you thought about stepping back from all of this for a few days and notice that you are wasting your time with these arguments?

Num fecisti?

> It doesn't matter how fast you can calculate a dot product or evaluate an activation function if the weights in question do not change.

That's a deliberate choice, not a fundamental requirement.

Models get frozen in order to become a product someone can put a version number on and ship, not because they must be, as demonstrated both by fine-tuning and by the initial training process — both of which update the weights.

> NNs as of right now are the equivalent of a brain scan.

First: see above.

Second: even if it were, so what? Look at the context I'm replying to, this is about energy efficiency — and applies just fine even when calculated for training the whole thing from scratch.

To put it another way: how long would it take a mouse to read 13 trillion tokens?

The energy cost of silicon vs. biology is lower than people realise, because people read the power consumption without considering that the speed of silicon is much higher: at the lowest level, the speed of silicon computation literally — not metaphorically, really literally — outpaces biological computation by the same magnitude to which jogging outpaces continental drift.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by Jensson on Saturday December 28, 2024 @12:16PM (#42532526)
> "FMA" meaning "fused multiply-add". It's the unit that matters for synapse-equivalents.

Neurons do so much more than a single math operation. A single cell can act as an intelligent little animal on its own, they are nothing like a neural network "neuron".

And note that all neurons act in parallel, so they are billions times more parallel than GPU's even if the operations would be the same.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ben_w on Saturday December 28, 2024 @12:27PM (#42532597)
A synapse is the reference for FMA operations, not a whole neuron.

> A single cell can act as an intelligent little animal on its own, they are nothing like a neural network "neuron".

Unless any of those things contribute to human intelligence, they do not matter in this context.

Cool, sure. Interesting, yes. But only important to exactly the degree to which any of that makes the human they're in smarter or dumber.

To the extent they're independently intelligent, they're the homunculi in Searle's Chinese Room.

> And note that all neurons act in parallel, so they are billions times more parallel than GPU's even if the operations would be the same.

Order of ten million times faster on a linear basis while still a thousand parallel operations.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by imtringued on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:32AM (#42530604)
Your numbers are meaningless because neuromorphic computing hardware exists in the context of often forgotten spiking neural networks, which actually try to mimic how biological neurons operate through voltage integration and programmable synapses and they tend to be significantly more efficient.

SpiNNaker needs 100kWh to simulate one billion neurons. So the rat wins in terms of energy efficiency.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ben_w on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:59AM (#42531091)
SpiNNaker is an academic experiment to see if taking more cues from biology would make the models better — it turned out the answer was "nobody in industry cares" because scaling the much simpler models to bigger neural nets and feeding them more data was good enough all by itself so far.

> and they tend to be significantly more efficient

Surely you noticed that this claim is false, just from your own next line saying it needing 100 kW (not "kWh" but I assume that's auto-corrupt) for a mere billion?

Even accounting for how neuron != synapse — one weight is closer to a single synapse; a brown rat has 200e6 neurons and about 450e9 synapses — the stated 100 kW for SpiNNaker is enough to easily drive simpler perceptron-type models of that scale, much faster than "real time".