News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by FredPret on Friday December 27, 2024 @11:39AM (#42523598)
If brown-rats-as-a-service is as useful as it is already, then I'm excited by what the future holds.

I think to make it to the next step, AI will have to have some way of performing rigorous logic integrated on a low level.

Maybe scaling that brown-rat brain will let it emulate an internal logical black box - much like the old adage about a sufficiently large C codebase containing an imperfect Lisp implementation - but I think things will get really cool we figure out how to wire together something like Wolfram Alpha, a programming language, some databases with lots of actual facts (as opposed to encoded/learned ones), and ChatGPT.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by cs702 on Friday December 27, 2024 @11:53AM (#42523739)
It's already better than real rats-as-a-service:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42449424

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by ndesaulniers on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:36PM (#42524711)
Does it matter what color the rat is?
Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by notpushkin on Friday December 27, 2024 @02:17PM (#42525144)
I suppose it refers to the particular species, Rattus norvegicus (although I'd call it common rat personally).
Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by petesergeant on Friday December 27, 2024 @02:32PM (#42525283)
ChatGPT can already run code, which allows it to overcome some limitations of tokenization (eg counting the letters in strawberry, sorting words by their second letter). Doesn't seem like adding a Prolog interpreter would be all that hard.
Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by Kim_Bruning on Friday December 27, 2024 @04:41PM (#42526301)
ChatGPT does already have access to Bing (would that count as your facts database?) and Jupyter (which is sort of a Wolphram clone except with Python?).

It still won't magically use them 100% correctly, but with a bit of smarts you can go a long way!

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by staunton on Friday December 27, 2024 @07:05PM (#42527286)
Jupyter is completely different from Wolfram software. It's just an interface to edit and run code (Julia, Python and R) and write/render text or images commenting the code. Which isn't to say that Jupyter isn't a great thing but I don't see how a Chatbot would produce better answers by having access to it in addition to "just Python".

Meanwhile, Wolfram software has built-in methods to solve a lot of different math problems for which in Python you would either need large (and sometimes quirky) libraries, if those libraries even exist.

Re:Does current AI represent a dead end? by Kim_Bruning on Saturday December 28, 2024 @10:32AM (#42531730)
Except a typical Jupyter environment -especially the one provided to ChatGPT- includes a lot of libraries; including numpy, scipy, pandas and plotly, which -while perhaps not quite as polished as wolphram (arguments can be made), can still rival it qua flexibility and functionality.

That and you need to actually expose python to GPT somehow, and Jupyter is not the worst way I suppose.

* The fact that Jupyter holds on to state means GPT doesn't need to write code from scratch for every step of the process.

* GPT can easily read back through the workbook to review errors or output from computations. GPT actually tries to correct errors even. Especially if it knows how to identify them.

To be sure, this is not magic. Consider it more like a tool with limited intelligence; but which can be controlled using natural language.

(Meanwhile, Anthropic allows Claude to run js with react, which is nice but seems less flexible in practice. I'm not sure Claude reads back.)