News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician by halayli on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:17AM (#42500479)
these numbers are just your perception. The way you ask the question will very much influence the output and certain topics more than others. I get much better results when I share my certainty levels in my questions and say things like "if at all", "if any" etc.
Re:Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician by mrbungie on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @10:19AM (#42502424)
Yeah, blame the users for "using it wrong" (phrase of the week I would say after the o3 discussions), and then sell the solution as almost-AGI.

PS: I'm starting to see a lot of plausible deniability in some comments about LLMs capabilites. When LLMs do great => "cool, we are scaling AI". when LLMs do something wrong => "user problem", "skill issues", "don't judge a fish for its ability to fly".

Re:Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician by vector_spaces on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:38AM (#42502977)
I agree with this approach and use it myself, but these confidence markers can also skew output in undesirable ways. All of these heuristics are especially fragile when the subject matter touches the frontiers of what is known.

In any case my best experiences with LLMs for pure math research have been for exploring the problem space and ideation -- queries along the line of "Here's a problem I'm working on ... . Do any other fields have a version of this problem, but framed differently?" or "Give me some totally left field methods, even if they are from different fields or unlikely to work. Assume I've exhausted all the 'obvious' approaches from field X"

Re:Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician by halayli on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @07:05AM (#42508397)
That's exactly how I use it. I find claude way more plesent to use than any other gpt I've used.
Re:Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician by amanda99 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:26PM (#42505391)
> these numbers are just your perception.

Of course they are, I hoped it was clear I was just sharing my experience trying to use it for research!

I did in general word it as I would a question to a researcher, which includes an uncertainty in it being true. E.g. this is from a recent prompt: "is this true in general, if not, what are the conditions for this to be true?"