This is, incidentally, basically how VC works too.
If everyone has the exact same expectations as you, no one is going to offer you the options trade structure at a price that would be profitable for you.
In the market there are ideas on all levels, some really are the $100 trade that will make money but that is the most possible to trade. However many ideas are on the large end where there is plenty of room for more people. If you think a fortune 100 company is under valued by $10/share you can make a ton of money (assuming you are right of course) and safely tell all your friends without affecting your ability to make money.
Inherent in this $10/share profit opportunity is that not everyone agrees with you. (If everyone did agree with you, the discrepancy/opportunity would collapse from $10 to under a penny.)
telling which is an evercise I can't help you with. I invest in index funds.