Re:Ask HN: Is StackOverflow being ruined by its mods?
by genwin on Sunday July 15, 2012 @07:06PM
(#4248483)
If the question was locked because it's a duplicate, I understand and agree with that. But it wasn't locked for being a duplicate; it was locked for being an off-topic question. I don't see how you've addressed that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Is StackOverflow being ruined by its mods?
by viraptor on Sunday July 15, 2012 @07:23PM
(#4248545)
There's a subtle problem with closing questions - basically there's a list to choose from and you can't always express exactly why you made that choice. Even when people agree on closing a question I can often see a wide spread of chosen options.
If you read into the FAQs / standards for questions, this one may not be off-topic, but is definitely low quality. Seeing the expression "is not considered a good, on-topic question", I would have to agree. If there's no specific option for "it's written in a bad way", then this would be the next natural choice. There's no initial research, no specific list of questions, silly title and a tone that would get edited pretty quickly these days.
Re:Ask HN: Is StackOverflow being ruined by its mods?
by ericb on Sunday July 15, 2012 @08:15PM
(#4248690)
If being a duplicate is why it is being closed, a search must have been done. Could not a link to the other offerings be given instead? Failing that, saying it is because of duplication?
Re:Ask HN: Is StackOverflow being ruined by its mods?
by viraptor on Sunday July 15, 2012 @08:40PM
(#4248758)
That's not the reason. All the posts listed above were actually created later ('09, '10) than the one from the main thread ('08). It's just a question that doesn't match the SO guidelines. It's not really bad, but it could be phrased better. Still - locked is probably better than closed here.