News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Watch with Android by draven on Thursday December 19, 2024 @10:46AM (#42462566)
Not OP but I have a Fenix 7x. What happens very infrequently is that I would wake up during the night, and then be absolutely still (I'm trying to go back to sleep) except for checking my watch every 15-20mn. This does not get detected as "awake" the following morning.

I don't really care because I got this watch so I can upload a track and follow it while recording various metrics during 5+ days, and for this it works perfectly.

Re:Apple Watch with Android by coredog64 on Thursday December 19, 2024 @11:28AM (#42463041)
There are two data points you need to accurately track sleep: Motion and respiration rate. With that information you can identify light sleep vs. deep sleep, and sometimes you can differentiate between light sleep and being still.

Source: Worked on the ResMed S+ and got a theory dump from the PhDs running the project.

Re:Apple Watch with Android by mandevil on Thursday December 19, 2024 @12:17PM (#42463568)
Sleep versus awake from a sensor on the wrist is always going to be subject to wide error bars.

Source: worked on an experiment trying to make people fall asleep while driving (in a simulated environment so it was safe- I built the simulated environment). It took a lot of EEG wires and gel in subject's hair etc. to accurately figure that out.

Re:Apple Watch with Android by draven on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:30AM (#42469276)
I would think that "pressing the button to turn on the backlight so I can check the time" would be a good indication that I'm awake :)
Re:Apple Watch with Android by MrMetlHed on Thursday December 19, 2024 @12:35PM (#42463797)
Same experience for me. If I wake up but lie still it's not nearly as accurate. What I do find useful is the Body Battery score, that generally maps well to how I feel the next day. And the Stress Score is an eerily good indicator of when I'm getting sick and when the illness is stopping.