News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by keithpeter on Saturday July 14, 2012 @02:54PM (#4245008)
"Because the companies leading the process are so productive, they pay high wages but do not employ many people. They may thus do little to reduce unemployment, while aggravating inequality."

That can't really carry on long term can it? Not much chance of infrastructure improvements without a tax base?

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by stcredzero on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:09PM (#4245048)
> That can't really carry on long term can it? Not much chance of infrastructure improvements without a tax base?

This is a problem for large political units going back to at least the Roman Empire.

The government should be doing everything it can to empower small businesses. It isn't because of two-party adversarial politics, however.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by lcargill99 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:34PM (#4245112)
"Empower" how? Subsidies? If you enact subsidies, then you create an environment in which somebody has the incentive to aggregate the subsidy - in a large business. That's agricultural policy in the US for the last hundred years in a nutshell.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by stcredzero on Saturday July 14, 2012 @05:00PM (#4245327)
Please, let's not have one of those debates.

I agree directly subsidizing businesses is foolish, in part for the reason you cite. I think there are lots of infrastructure-like things that could be provided, including healthcare. There is clearly something broken in US healthcare. It doesn't function as useful market for individuals and small businesses. There's clearly something screwy with the economics of it.

You can have the last word. I have to go sell my car.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by ams6110 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @08:49PM (#4245747)
When did healthcare become "broken" in the US? It hasn't always been so, back to 1776, right? I think the answer is pretty obvious.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by jandrewrogers on Saturday July 14, 2012 @09:19PM (#4245786)
It became broken as a side effect of wage control regulations during WW2 that encouraged healthcare to be tied to employers. The second world war is long over but this particular unintended consequence is still with us.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by nazgulnarsil on Saturday July 14, 2012 @07:45PM (#4245656)
cutting taxes =/= subsidy.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by HotKFreshSwag on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:20PM (#4245076)
Not so much two-party adversarial politics so much as big business and the 0.01% funding and controlling the two viable parties. The center-right party and the right party used to compromise. The system wasn't always this dysfunctional but one party has been hijacked by fringe groups who refuse to compromise.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by troyastorino on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:11PM (#4245055)
Ultimately there are going to have to be shifts in what skills people learn. There will be high unemployment during the adjustment period, but as long as demand for low-skill jobs shrinks, people will adjust and learn new skills. You don't have to go back to school to learn how to be a programmer :)
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by dangrossman on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:30PM (#4245098)
Two faulty assumptions:

1) That for every low-skill job lost, a high-skill job replaces it. That's not the case. When robotic arms replace 100k factory workers, the robotic arm companies do not need 100k new programmers, nor are the factory owners going to use the reduced labor costs to turn into software shops. It's not like the industrial revolution all over again; computers and robotics are producing such enormous productivty gains that eventually there will be fewer people required by the labor force than the working-age population.

2) That people whose skills are no longer in-demand will somehow acquire other skills. Some will, but large swaths of the unemployed won't, especially among people 50+. That's why so many millions, especially 50+ women, have now been unemployed for years. It's not such an easy transition as you make it out to be -- people won't simply adjust, no, a large portion will essentially drop from middle-class to poverty and stay that way until they die. It's not they who will take the new jobs, it's the younger next generation that never had the obsolete skills.

A 55 year old with only a HS diploma for whom a computer has never been more than a magical toaster that delivers e-mail, only existing in the past few years of his/her life, is simply not going to become a professional programmer even if he/she wanted to.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by chernevik on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:46PM (#4245294)
The productivity improvements of particular individuals needn't be so drastic as going from assembly line worker to computer programmer.

(Bear in mind that not all "assembly lines" or "programmers" are the same -- there are very likely line workers at Boeing who are multiples more productive than programmers at [big Fortune 500 company of your choice].)

Workers can improve productivity by taking jobs that are otherwise less desirable. Maybe they have to commute further, or work shifts they don't prefer. There is a small segment of the workforce that can improve its productivity just by showing up on time. Some folks will have to make more drastic changes, such as moving. Many people moved to Florida to build houses that, as it turns out, no one wants. Those people won't find construction work in Florida but might well find it in North Dakota, which is currently going bonkers.

And they can seek retrainings that might seem marginal. Maybe they learn to weld, or operate a crane. A semi-literate adult who buckles down achieve actual literacy probably opens very large possiblities for productivity gains.

So moving up the productivity curve doesn't mean learning 55 year olds learning Python. It can mean finding a way to do 5%, 10% 20% better.

That said, I have to agree that improving productivity is a lot easier for people with sound education and training to begin with. One of our great problems is the failure of our schooling culture to properly prepare people to understand and learn new things.

EDITED TO ADD: Also, I don't want to sound ignorant of all the difficulties of this. Some gains are easily achieved, some are hard won but worthwhile for non-economic reasons. And some of the sacrifices required are pretty hard. It is one thing for economists to talk about "labor mobility" as a factor driving productivity, and another for those who find they have to move half-way across the country.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by potatolicious on Saturday July 14, 2012 @09:16PM (#4245784)
> " When robotic arms replace 100k factory workers, the robotic arm companies do not need 100k new programmers"

This is entirely true, but was also true in the industrial revolution. With the increasing efficiency of manufacturing we've seen a tremendous growth in service industries that are absorbing a large portion of the displaced workforce.

Whether or not that ratio is 1:1 is hard to guess, though I suspect not quite.

The real problem here is not so much lack of jobs, but like you mentioned, it's nigh-impossible to actually transition people from one field to another. We've outright eliminated most manual and unskilled labor, and what remains is disappearing quickly. The jobs that people had, vs. the jobs that they must now pursue are incredibly different, and most people aren't going to make that jump successfully.

We are dealing with an entire lost generation, if not more.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by lcargill99 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:36PM (#4245120)
The theory says that workers with low marginal productivity can move up the productivity scale. And largely, that's what's seen, but it's far from perfect.
Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by ams6110 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @08:52PM (#4245751)
A 55 year old with only a HS diploma for whom a computer has never been more than a magical toaster that delivers e-mail, only existing in the past few years of his/her life, is simply not going to become a professional programmer even if he/she wanted to.

I disagree, if he really wanted to, he could. I do agree that most don't/won't. At that age, most people have low motivation to start over.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by potatolicious on Saturday July 14, 2012 @09:27PM (#4245804)
I disagree, though I used to believe the same.

What you're discounting is that people are born with vastly different mental capabilities - I'm quite certain everyone on HN is at least in the top 20% of the country, and it's easy for us to assume that, just because we've encountered few hard caps on our mental abilities, that others are the same.

What changed my mind was working in a factory - where I had months to hang out with line workers, machinists, technicians, and just shoot the shit with them. My takeaway from it is: a lot of them simply do not have the intelligence to operate in many highly technical jobs. This isn't a slight on them - they're amazing, worthwhile human beings, but it's unreasonable to expect them to be able to write code, even given an arbitrarily large amount of training. For every IQ 120, there is an IQ 80. Remember that.

The other side of it is that our school system performs appallingly poorly, and fails a lot of the population. Even if someone had the natural intelligence and aptitude, for a lot of them their educational background is so poor that there is no meaningful way for them to catch up, ever. A person of solid intellect who, for whatever reasons, barely made his way out of high school math, is not going to be able to pick up a CS curriculum. The foundation we're working from is not very solid.

The third component is of course the system - if someone wanted to retrain as a professional programmer from a factory job, and let's assume magically that he/she has the intelligence to do it, and unexpectedly did really well in school a long time ago. They're about as ideally positioned as one can be... except who's going to pay for the retraining? Who's going to hire the 40 year-old who just got into programming? Even when you have created the ideal state, the person's odds are still horrible.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by ams6110 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:04PM (#4245972)
You're probably right on a lot of this. But being a programmer doesn't require exceptional intelligence. Normal intelligence, yes. And a fair amount of patience. An ability to not get frustrated, to understand that things NOT working right away is normal. But it's not that hard. And you don't need to go through a formal CS curriculum to be a productive programmer. I don't think it's a cakewalk; I certainly know 50-somthings who I don't think could do it. Not a chance in fact. But I do think it's possible for some.

I wonder what we're all going to do when humans doing app development by writing code becomes obsolete. Yes, it will happen.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by potatolicious on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:25PM (#4246005)
There are a lot of people of below-normal intelligence out there. Keep in mind that by definition 50% of the world has an IQ below 100 - that's a very, very large chunk of our work force that simply cannot pull off, say, programming, data science, or the myriad of technical jobs that are now in-demand.

> "But it's not that hard."

It wasn't for you, evidently, and it wasn't really for me either, but for a lot of people it strains at the edge of their ability to comprehend and mentally model, even with practice. That's the point I'm making: we've been born into the portion of the population that can, with some elbow grease, grok it. Not everyone is as fortunate. Even some of the ones who are, lack the educational background - in math, in logic, in whatever - to make that leap.

It took working a wildly different job, with a wildly different demographic, to really comprehend just how wide that gap is.

Even if we could successfully retrain, say, 20% of the industrial work force into knowledge-based jobs, that's still a lot of people out in the cold, and even then - who would pay for the retraining, which for a lot of people would take years? Who will bankroll their education, or even their living costs, while this transition occurs?

There are so many systemic problems with this it's mind-boggling. Suffice it to say, the notion that displaced workers from now-collapsed industries can retrain and reapply elsewhere is dramatically oversimplified. The reality is that the vast majority will never make the leap anywhere else.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by lesterbuck on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:04PM (#4245188)
Brynjolfsson and McAfee deal with the stresses on societies to keep up with technology:

http://www.amazon.com/Race-Against-The-Machine-ebook/dp/B005...

Unfortunately, the rate of technological acceleration is increasing, and society is not able to keep up with even the current rate, viz. the huge numbers of unemployed workers with outdated skills. They suggest that the disruptions we have experienced over the last ten years are just a hint of the disruptions coming over the next ten years, with increasing rates of change. It is the elephant in the room for the presidential campaign, but is pretty much being ignored by both sides. They even suggest that in ten years or so, all that manufacturing in China could move back to US soil as factories become completely robotic.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by Artistry121 on Sunday July 15, 2012 @12:49AM (#4246162)
Wouldn't there be a fairly simple solution in lowering the working schedules of Americans as a whole? (Simple in idea, not in execution)

With all the productivity improvements couldn't workweek hours decrease causing a rise in the number of people employed (maybe at a cost of less take home pay for workers overall)?

Musings.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by adventureful on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:06PM (#4245194)
America doesn't have a tax base problem, it has a spending priority problem. The total government system in the US collects more in taxes than the entire German economy is worth. You'd think we could have nice roads given that. The problem is what that money is being spent on.

Our tax system is also extraordinarily complex, with thousands of taxes, and a tax code that the IRS doesn't even fully understand. Individual Americans spend $300+ billion (last I recall reading) just preparing their taxes each year.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by rayiner on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:17PM (#4245216)
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/nov/...

If a number seems hard to believe, it probably is. Think it through--how many hours do you spend doing your taxes each year? A few hours? How many hours do you spend showering and brushing your teeth each year?

Maybe it's businesses--but the entire US legal sector is only about $150 billion.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by lsc on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:31PM (#4245917)
eh. most people don't correctly fill out their taxes.

Did you pay your use taxes? (actually, I believe that has been simplified, in california, allowing you to pay a flat fee now.)

If you ordered anything from amazon tax free, well, you should have filed your use taxes. I know one person, besides me, that does, and I pay someone else to do it.

There are all sorts of other little gotchas, even if you are an employee on a 1040EZ.

Also, this complexity leads to incredible risk; I mean, I generally don't mind paying taxes. (I mean, I'd like to pay less, but eh, I've shopped around, and the rates here are pretty okay for what I need and what I get.) but I fear nothing like I fear the tax man. With almost any other tax mistake? the worst that can happen is corporate and personal bankruptcy.

Now, screw up your taxes? yeah, you aren't particularly likely to go to jail, I mean, assuming you weren't trying to commit fraud, but it is pretty easy to end up with a whole lot of debt that you can't run out on.

Because of this, I outsource nearly all my accounting and bookkeeping. and yeah, it costs money, but as far as I can tell? it's the only insurance I can buy against one of the very few (likely) events that can put me in debt for life.

(Now, obviously, this is only scary because I have a low-margin business with revenue that is substantial compared to my personal earning power; if the IRS reclassified some of my revenue as income? it wouldn't take very much to put me in the red. If you are on a 1040ez and you miss your use tax and get audited? eh, it's not a bankruptcy event.)

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by lsc on Sunday July 15, 2012 @04:35PM (#4248006)
meh

>With almost any other tax mistake?

Should be

With almost any other business mistake?

I mean, if I sign a 5 year lease on the small house I'm spending every year on datacenter space, then the company crashes? eh, bankruptcy.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by adventureful on Saturday July 14, 2012 @05:11PM (#4245362)
I don't hire someone to brush my teeth for me at $65 / hour or $250 / hour etc.

The US Government disagrees with you.

"The cost of preparing and filing all business and personal tax returns is estimated to be $250 to $300 billion each year. According to a 2005 report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office, the efficiency cost of the tax system—the output that is lost over and above the tax itself—is between $240 billion and $600 billion per year."

"The Government Accountability Office (GAO) is the audit, evaluation, and investigative arm of the United States Congress. It is part of the legislative branch of the United States government."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_preparation

A tax is a burden imposed upon me by an external force. In the case of taxes it's generally completely involuntary. I voluntarily brush my teeth. There's a very, very, very large difference between having a time and financial cost imposed upon you, and choosing to spend a few dollars and x hours per month on brushing my teeth.

If someone is imposing a tax upon you, it's properly their responsibility to make sure it's as efficient and as non-painful as possible (in terms of time to file, added costs, etc). The US Government has completely failed in that regard. It's almost universally agreed (aka bi-partisan) that we have a disaster of a tax code complication wise.

1.75 million accountants in the US. That's about 60% more than there are lawyers.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by rayiner on Saturday July 14, 2012 @06:07PM (#4245492)
> I don't hire someone to brush my teeth for me at $65 / hour or $250 / hour etc.

But that's not how the numbers you're pointing to were generated. They put a $39/hour figure on the time people spent to do their own taxes. My point is that if you put a $39/hour figure on say brushing and showering, you get something like $15,000 per year spent on personal hygiene, about 1/2 of the individual income.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by pash on Sunday July 15, 2012 @02:59AM (#4246374)
You brush your teeth so your mouth doesn't taste like shit and your teeth don't fall out. You hire an accountant to do your taxes because the tax code cannot be understood by anyone who hasn't devoted his life to deciphering it.

The difference is that there's not a damn thing you can do about your teeth getting dirty (but brush them), but the tax code could be a hell of a lot simpler if only they'd stop making it more complicated.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by anigbrowl on Saturday July 14, 2012 @05:34PM (#4245418)
1.75 million accountants in the US.

A good number of whom are vested in keeping things complicated.

Re:America’s economy is once again reinventing itself by tptacek on Sunday July 15, 2012 @04:51PM (#4248070)
A bit cynical. Taxes for the majority of Americans are simple enough to be done without accountants, and even without any kind of tax filing software. Meanwhile, no matter how simple or complicated the tax codes get, businesses will always need accountants.