News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:10PM (#42447216)
[delayed]
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by Alupis on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:18PM (#42447542)
Progressive income tax is also silly. Just because you earn more money than someone else doesn't mean you derive more benefits from the government.

The idea of "Paying what you can afford" is BS everywhere it's been implemented - from school tuition to soccer camp to taxes. Everyone feels burned and like the "others" aren't paying what they should be.

Federal taxes should be a flat percentage, no deductions, no credits, no so-called "loop holes"... nothing. Every citizen pays the same percentage (whatever it needs to be).

The incumbent tax apparatus would never allow us to have something so simple, though.

For a nation that got it's start in no small part due to being over-taxed, it's very interesting to see just how much tax shenanigans we tolerate today.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @10:31PM (#42447892)
Our philosophies differ.

> Progressive income tax is also silly. Just because you earn more money than someone else doesn't mean you derive more benefits from the government.

I think "pay what you can afford" is fair because the only way to make half a million dollars (or more) a year is to disproportionately reap the benefits of society. Marginal income tax is fair in the sense that everyone does pay the same. Your $11,001st dollar is taxed the same as everyone else, just like your $578,126th dollar. If you don't want to pay the highest rates then take advantage of deductions (aka incentives aka loopholes) and invest in creating jobs.

> Everyone feels burned and like the "others" aren't paying what they should be.

I definitely don't feel this way and I am happy to pay my marginal rates. I just don't think they go far enough.

> Federal taxes should be a flat percentage, no deductions, no credits, no so-called "loop holes"... nothing. Every citizen pays the same percentage (whatever it needs to be).

Do you propose a flat income tax or a flat wealth tax? Should capital gains be taxed as income?

> For a nation that got it's start in no small part due to being over-taxed, it's very interesting to see just how much tax shenanigans we tolerate today.

My understanding was that the issue was lack of representation or ability to levy local taxes but I admit my knowledge of that point in history is weak. The America of today is certainly different from revolutionary times. I would say it is better.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by Alupis on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @02:34PM (#42454046)
> disproportionately reap the benefits of society

This is where we fundamentally disagree.

You buy products because you want/like them. The people who make them are not disproportionately reaping benefits of society - they are reaping benefits of creating productive and desirable products.

This view flirts with the idea that people "extract" wealth from the public, and that people are taken advantage of and/or manipulated into buying things.

> I definitely don't feel this way and I am happy to pay my marginal rates. I just don't think they go far enough.

People universally feel the government (local, state, federal) overwhelmingly wastes their tax money - yet so many people demand others pay more of their earned income to this uncaring ineffective machine. Tax receipts will never be enough for the government, and some people will continue to advocate plowing more of other people's money into the dark abyss. That's madness.

> Do you propose a flat income tax or a flat wealth tax? Should capital gains be taxed as income?

I propose a straight flat income tax percentage, without any deductions, credits, anything. While the percentage is fixed, the dollar amount obviously scales with income. Things like capital gains are solved this way by taxing the actual income you generated from the investments.

I'm making up numbers, but say it's 20%. No matter if you earned $1 of income, or $1,000,000 - you pay 20%.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @03:30PM (#42454768)
I think a person who gains $10,000,000.00 a year should be paying a higher tax than someone gaining $20,000.00 a year because a person can’t personally create $10,000,000.00 of value in a year. Or even $8,000,000.00 of value. The only way to do that is to own a disproportionate slice of the American economy. When money moves value is created. The incentive should be to spread that wealth out, not to concentrate it.

A flat tax of 20% would be ruinous to the poor and lower middle class. That can’t be sustained without an enormous increase in income or some guarantees around living expenses.

If I understand your definition of flat tax then capital gains would be untaxed as well so the wealthiest would pay even less.

I understand the ideology. Taxes should be simple and equal. I just don’t think that ideology is worth defending. The price is too high when the benefits are so unclear.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by Alupis on Thursday December 19, 2024 @01:02PM (#42464070)
> because a person can’t personally create $10,000,000.00 of value in a year. Or even $8,000,000.00 of value. The only way to do that is to own a disproportionate slice of the American economy.

This is a very problematic view of the world, and is not in line with reality.

The people who earn $10MM a year make decisions that impact the lives of thousands (10's of thousands, or 100's of thousands) of employees. They are usually also directly responsible for millions of dollars in salaries every month.

The myth that executives running a business don't earn their pay is silly.

> A flat tax of 20% would be ruinous to the poor and lower middle class.

Also not true even a little bit. Most of the lower and middle class already pay more than 20%.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Thursday December 19, 2024 @06:20PM (#42466767)
> The people who earn $10MM a year make decisions that impact the lives of thousands (10's of thousands, or 100's of thousands) of employees.

But those decisions are worthless without people to carry them out.

> They are usually also directly responsible for millions of dollars in salaries every month.

So what? The salaries may add up to millions but what’s the denominator? This doesn’t justify a 100x multiplier on earnings.

> Also not true even a little bit. Most of the lower and middle class already pay more than 20%.

Are you including sales, property, and state income tax?

Median income in the US is $80,610.00. The effective federal income tax rate at that income level is 16.23% but that assumes no deductions. In reality the median earner is going to take the standard deduction for $13,850.00 so they’re only going to pay federal income tax on $66,760.00 so their effective rate is 15.04%. This doesn’t consider student loan payments, mortgage interest deductions, or retirement account contributions, which will further lower the effective rate.

This is for the median income. For lower incomes the effect is even more dramatic.

So the only way most of the lower and middle class pay more than 20% is if you count all taxes paid. But that means for your flat 20%-no-deductions tax to be a better deal it has to come with an abolition of all other taxes.

If so how do municipalities get funding? Does it all come from the federal government?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tzs on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @02:47AM (#42448772)
> Progressive income tax is also silly. Just because you earn more money than someone else doesn't mean you derive more benefits from the government

Ok...

> Federal taxes should be a flat percentage, no deductions, no credits, no so-called "loop holes"... nothing. Every citizen pays the same percentage (whatever it needs to be).

Flat percentage? A flat percentage means that if you earn N times what someone else earns you pay N times as much tax as they do.

But you just said a couple of paragraphs earlier that just because you earn more money that someone else doesn't mean you derive more benefits from the government. If that's going to be the basis of your tax policy shouldn't the tax be a flat amount?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by Alupis on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:41PM (#42452814)
A flat percentage means exactly that - everyone pays the same percentage. Everyone derives the same value from the government, ie. the same percentage of their income.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @03:58PM (#42455099)
Doesn’t this imply philosophically that the government provides our income?

I see it more like income is derived from our economy, which belongs to everyone. The government just sets the rules.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tzs on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @03:20PM (#42454634)
Let's say the flat percentage is 10%.

Alice makes $10 million/year, so her tax is $1 million/year.

Bob makes $20 000/year, so his tax is $2 000/year.

Alice and Bob get the same benefits from the government so what is the justification for her tax being 500 times as much as Bob's?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by Alupis on Thursday December 19, 2024 @01:05PM (#42464094)
If you want to make it a flat dollar amount, you won't find an argument from me.

I happen to think a flat percentage without deductions or credits is the best compromise with the people who think everyone else isn't paying their "fair share". If everyone pays this 10% (or whatever) then there's no quibbling about this or that deduction or tax shenanigan (buying art, etc).

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tzs on Thursday December 19, 2024 @06:54PM (#42467006)
Having a progressive rate with no deductions or credits would also accomplish getting rid of the quibbling.

The big argument for a progressive rate over a fixed rate is that 10% from someone making $15 000 has a much bigger impact on their lifestyle than 10% from someone making $15 000 000.

With no deductions and credits 10% on $15 000, especially for someone with kids, can mean the tax is coming from money that otherwise would have went toward basic things like food and heat and healthcare.

That's why nearly every serious flat rate tax proposal I've seen includes some kind of exemption so that tax is actually only on the income over that threshold. But once you do that it is now a progressive tax with two brackets.