News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by sudobash1 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:45PM (#42447065)
Should have (2017)

I noticed that when it said at the start:

> five giant F-1 rocket engines—still the most powerful ever built

This is no longer the case. The SpaceX Starship has the Saturn V beat nowdays.

(Edit: I suppose the F-1 rocket engines still have the Raptor 2 engines beat, so the article is still correct. The Starship just has more engines than the Saturn V for more thrust)

Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by nickmcc on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:46PM (#42447072)
An individual F1 engine outperforms an individual Raptor 2/3.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by sudobash1 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:49PM (#42447098)
I just realized that after hitting post. Edited my comment.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by Polizeiposaune on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:33PM (#42447317)
Depends on the metric.

F1 is still the winner in sea level thrust per engine (6770 kN vs 2660kN).

Raptor is more efficient (with higher sea level and vacuum specific impulse); it also has a much higher thrust density -- those 2660kN come from a nozzle only 1.3m in diameter, vs the F1's 3.7m diameter.

The higher thrust density and smaller size means that you can fit 33 raptors in a ~9m diameter circle and end up with a stage with double the thrust of the ~10m diameter Saturn V.

Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by pfdietz on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @10:57PM (#42447998)
Raptor also has twice the thrust/weight ratio of the F-1.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:05PM (#42447183)
The line you quoted specifically says F-1 engine, not Saturn V rocket.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by GuB-42 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:48PM (#42447386)
SpaceX Starship is closer to the (failed) N1 Soviet Rocket which should have been the Saturn V competitor.

The N1, with its 30 NK-15 engine would have made it more powerful than the Saturn V and its 5 F-1 engine, but less powerful than SpaceX "Super Heavy" with its 33 Raptor engines.

Another similarity is that the NK-15 engine and the Raptor are both staged combustion engines, while the F-1 uses the simpler open cycle design. The F-1 is also much more powerful than both the Raptor and NK-15, that's why the Saturn V has only 5 of them.

The similarities end there, fortunately.

Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by Aloha on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:10PM (#42447511)
The difference is, we have better QC procedures and modern flight control electronics.
Re:We Built the Saturn V (2017) by avmich on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:54PM (#42447413)
F-1 vs. Raptor question is only for American engines, not the world ones. If by "most powerful" you mean engine thrust.