That's so fascinating to me! "Howdy" definitely ranks higher on my hokey-ness scale than "y'all".
Love a good "over yonder" though.
I grew up mostly in the north and talk very northernly, but somehow the only exception is that 'howdy' became my standard greeting. 'yall' feels like too much, but 'howdy' just rolls off the tongue so smoothly. Other greetings always sound too terse (hi, hey), too formal (hello), or are questions (how's it going, what's up) which I just loathe. Though technically howdy is sort of a question too, coming from 'how do you do'.
What's 'a piece'? Don't think I've heard that one.
Re:In Defense of Y'All
by hotsauceror on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:18AM
(#42471811)
"A piece" is a measure of distance, longer than "over yonder", shorter than "a ways".
"She lives up the road a piece."
I unapologetically, unironically use "howdy", "a piece", "a ways", "over yonder", "get to goin'", and "fixin' to". But "y'all" is a bridge too far.