I’m advocating against wasting public money on nuclear power pretending it is a solution to climate change.
Have at it with your own money.
I already provided you with the scientists and engineers, but you seem to have completely disregarded them because they did not align with what you wanted.
I can do it again:
The research disagrees with you. Whenever new built nuclear power is included in the analysis the results becomes prohibitively expensive.
> Focusing on the case of Denmark, this article investigates a future fully sector-coupled energy system in a carbon-neutral society and compares the operation and costs of renewables and nuclear-based energy systems.
> The study finds that investments in flexibility in the electricity supply are needed in both systems due to the constant production pattern of nuclear and the variability of renewable energy sources.
> However, the scenario with high nuclear implementation is 1.2 billion EUR more expensive annually compared to a scenario only based on renewables, *with all systems completely balancing supply and demand across all energy sectors in every hour*.
> For nuclear power to be cost competitive with renewables an investment cost of 1.55 MEUR/MW must be achieved, which is substantially below any cost projection for nuclear power.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...
Or if you want a more southern latitude you have Australia here:
https://www.csiro.au/-/media/Energy/GenCost/GenCost2024-25Co...
You agree it costs more, is less flexible, takes longer to be operational than renewable energies.
You didn’t present any good argument for nuclear except “something something you don’t like my politics”
I agree with GP that nuclear is often used as a smokescreen to delay doing __anything__ practical and instead keep burning coal etc
Since the nuclear phase out began both coal and nuclear is down replaced by renewables. Fossil gas is stable.
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-elec-by-source?time...
Germany brought a few coal plants out mothball to prevent the collapse of the French grid when half the French nuclear fleet was off line at the height of the energy crisis.
Which then were promptly mothballed again when the French got their nuclear power under control.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/15/business/nuclear-power-fr...
But lets blame the French nuclear power not delivering on Germany. That makes total sense.
it sounds like they turned off coal to go back to nuclear after all...
This is not something you can answer clearly, no one can.
I personally would say since renewables (there are many different types of renewable energy sources btw) are so much cheaper and easier to build they are more consistent.
France for example has really shitty nuclear plants that have been falling apart since the 90s - they are not reliable and fixing them is not feasible
Storage delivering nuclear scale energy day in and day out in California:
https://blog.gridstatus.io/caiso-batteries-apr-2024/
Storage plummeting in cost 20% YoY, now at $66/kWh.
https://reneweconomy.com.au/mind-blowing-battery-cell-prices...
Many grids around the world already spent loads of time with renewables filling 100% of the demand. That is a down right hostile environment for nuclear power which relies on being able to output at 100% 24/7 all year around to only be horrifically expensive.
https://www.power-technology.com/news/california-achieves-10...
In the land of infinite resources and infinite time "all of the above" is a viable answer. In the real world we neither have infinite resources nor infinite time to fix climate change.
Lets focus our limited resources on what works and instead spend the big bucks on decarbonizing truly hard areas like aviation, construction, shipping and agriculture.