Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by hansvm on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:51PM
(#42443469)
> Law should be understandable by the layman, else how does someone know if they have broken it?
This is especially important in a world where precious few scenarios allow ignorance as a legal defense.
Re:MIT study explains why laws are written in an incomprehen...
by kristianbrigman on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @01:11PM
(#42443658)
I'd prefer to keep the separation of powers intact (legislature writes/modifies laws, judiciary can strike them down but can't (or isn't supposed to) make up law... the exchange is not that different between development and QA :)
your process seems reasonable though.
I'd prefer it if previous cases had a bearing on rewriting/amending laws, rather than influencing a current case, and if the feeling is that a current judgement was not correct, rewrite/refine the law taking the case into account.
That way a judgement does not require previous case research, this does mean that law needs to become a more well specified, and unambiguous language. We have decades of classification and computer language theory to draw from, and LLMs to stub-translate existing law, with exceptions going to a dead-letter-queue for individual appraisal.
Law should be understandable by the layman, else how does someone know if they have broken it?