News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by PommeDeTerre on Saturday July 14, 2012 @09:34AM (#4244114)
Anyone who has been in the software industry for a while now will have noticed the recent influx of people who I will refer to as "the Creatives".

Most of them are decent people, and I'll go for a beer with them any time. But what they bring to the software they're working on usually isn't beneficial.

Put bluntly, they care more about the look and aesthetics of software, rather than its usability and practicality. As these people have become more and more involved with software development over the past 5 to 7 years, we've started to see more and more problems arise.

Long-time Phoenix/Firebird/Firefox users will know what I mean. Each round of "improvements" to the UI by these creative types has in fact made it much worse. The usability has suffered greatly. Unfortunately, these people also apparently have great influence at Google and Apple, so alternate browsers like Chrome and Safari have UIs that are just as bad, if not worse in some ways.

My suspicion is that the same thing has happened at Microsoft, and Windows 8 and Metro are just this problem becoming extremely obvious on a wide scale. If Windows 8 and Metro are huge failures, as they very well may be, it will probably become clear that we need to ditch these UIs that focus on being pretty above all else.

The industry as a whole will need to return to simpler UIs and that are usable, functional and practical. We'll need to leave this dark period behind us, but hopefully we can learn from these mistakes to ensure future applications do not fall victim to the problems we are witnessing today.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by kiba on Saturday July 14, 2012 @09:49AM (#4244142)
The industry as a whole will need to return to simpler UIs and that are usable, functional and practical. We'll need to leave this dark period behind us, but hopefully we can learn from these mistakes to ensure future applications do not fall victim to the problems we are witnessing today.

Well, you have to qualify why Chrome's UI sucks, otherwise it's just an opinion. As far as I am concerned, it is useful plenty.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by jaems33 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:15AM (#4244200)
Indeed. Years ago, they took a bold choice to use one input box for both searching and url's and now it's one major reason why I use Chrome over Firefox and Safari.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by Wilya on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:57AM (#4244321)
Fun fact: In 1999, Mozilla (around its M11 release) introduced a "Search" button to the location field [0] which meant a unified input box. Firefox and its two-field setup is, absurdly enough, a later move. I can't point out when it happened, or if it was already there in the earliest days.. The single box is still there in Seamonkey, though, iirc.

[0] http://www.andrewturnbull.net/mozilla/history.html

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by cdr on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:27AM (#4244235)
Firefox's bar works exactly the same as Chrome's now. And even long before FF started letting you search from the address bar without search keywords, you could use search keywords.

I prefer the in-bar history searching in FF too.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by Silhouette on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:14AM (#4244366)
Firefox's bar works exactly the same as Chrome's now.

Is it exactly the same? In Firefox, AFAIK you don't get every URL you type sent off to Google for logging as part of the instant search system; that only happens with things you type in the separate search box. In Chrome, I'm not sure whether it's the default for a new installation at the moment, but that capability is definitely there for anything you type in the (only) box.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by cdr on Saturday July 14, 2012 @02:15PM (#4244922)
I meant exactly the same as far as an average user is concerned - you never have to use the search box (I remove it), you can just put search terms in the main box and it'll use the configured provider.

I will admit FF is a little worse at confusing search terms for a URL on occasion, but that's a minor annoyance at best.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by Silhouette on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:31PM (#4245101)
It wasn't the annoyance I was commenting on, but rather the privacy implications of combining the two bars when what you would type in one of them is typically sent off to some search engine somewhere in real time.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by bgilroy26 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:54AM (#4244484)
It's the same almost all of the time, but some searches with colons will be run through the URL path instead because it thinks you meant http://
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by poutine on Saturday July 14, 2012 @01:20PM (#4244748)
Safari in 10.8 works in a similar way as Chrome does with the address bar. Indeed it seems to be faster too, I'm toying with switching from Chrome. We shall see.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by ams6110 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @12:54PM (#4244672)
Indeed, it's hard to knock Chrome's UI, it barely has one.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by pinaceae on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:01AM (#4244161)
see, and I for one am glad that this happened and that the classic nerds with no visual taste whatsoever have been driven back to where they belong - the backend.

Using Chrome as an example is really, really funny.

How about GIMP? Every Linux distro before Ubuntu? Lotus Notes?

Yes, one thing has been lost though - that smug feeling of eliteness, being able to do something with a computer no normal user could. Like attaching a printer and having it print right away. Or being able to setup a photo album, import them from a bunch of devices and upload it to a safe off-site location.

Now grandma can do it and it sucks, right? She doesn't it even know how it works! Unfair!

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by RivieraKid on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:27AM (#4244404)
I like UIs that have wow effect and shallow learning curve. But this fades off quickly - after you get used to it, you don't take any pleasure from the looks of the UI. What matters in the long term is efficiency and features.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by tomjen3 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:07AM (#4244352)
With that kind of attitude, why are you here?
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by FreshCode on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:05AM (#4244179)
If anything, Apple has shown us that design does matter and I feel like software (especially websites) is getting more usable over time. Your discontent over changing UIs seem like those of a long-time user upset by someone moving their cheese. I didn't like Chrome's spartan UI at first, but it won me over.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by RivieraKid on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:29AM (#4244410)
Apple set a trend of prioritizing learning curve and aesthetics over long term efficiency and features. I understand why some poeple don't like that.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by gurkendoktor on Saturday July 14, 2012 @01:50PM (#4244857)
How so - what exactly are you missing?

You have the basic Cocoa interface with accessibility features. You have OS X' default helpers, mostly the "Help" menu that allows you to search for menu items. You have AppleScriptability for lots of apps, even some third-party apps written by "designer" folks like Things. Then there is Automator. And below all that, you are free to do whatever you want from the Terminal.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by RivieraKid on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:17PM (#4245067)
OS X has several problems:

* I can't multitask as efficiently as in Linux or Windows (it has several reasons).

* Most windows can't be maximized (perhaps there's an app for this).

* Select text to copy and paste with middle click doesn't work.

* Full font hinting can't be set. Linux has better font rendering than OS X / Windows (if configured properly).

* The whole system feels too closed and constrained. In Linux, I know that if there's something I don't like, I can usually fix it.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by superuser2 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @03:15PM (#4245063)
I hear this argument all the time, but I don't get it. Besides software that 3rd parties choose not to write for OSX, what functionality is possible on Windows but impossible on OSX?
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by RivieraKid on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:15AM (#4244370)
There's some truth to what you're saying. Gnome 3, Unity and Metro are simply worse desktop environments than their previous versions. They are aiming for touch-friendliness and for some reason trying to radically change what was working fine. Both of these are massive mistakes.

BTW Chrome's UI is almost perfect (including OS and mobile browser). The people behid it must be one of the best in the industry.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by rahoulb on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:20AM (#4244211)
Usability and practicality is down for the likes of us. But for the vast majority of people, who used to despise computers, a whole new world has opened up. We are the minority here.
Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by PommeDeTerre on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:40AM (#4244276)
I'm not certain that's true. What I think has happened is that more people are living in ignorance of what their software could be doing.

Instead of the traditional rule of 80% of people using 20% of an application's functionality, we now have 95% of people using 3%. They aren't even aware that the other 97% exists, even if that functionality would be very useful to them.

Take Chrome, for instance. Much of the functionality is hidden away under a single menu, far on the right, that isn't even obviously a menu.

I've worked directly with a number of "average" people now who moved to Chrome because it was recommended to them by somebody else, but they didn't even know about its main menu. You wouldn't believe their surprise when they see that Chrome allows them to open multiple tabs or windows, or that they can zoom the page, or that they can print.

These aren't stupid people, either. They're accountants, lawyers, doctors, nurses, and other non-technical, but well-educated and intelligent, people. Some of them have been using computers for decades. But Chrome's poor UI design hid useful functionality from them, rather than making it obvious like traditional menus under a permanently-visible menu bar used to do.

Being unaware of Chrome's main menu, the users were also never aware of the keyboard shortcuts. Along with a highly-simplified toolbar, these prevented them from even realizing that Chrome could do anything beyond browsing a single web page at a time.

So while software today may be easier to use for typical people, I suspect that's only because it's giving them an experience that's extremely basic. These people will be very happy that Chrome's a fast web browser, but they'll silently be disappointed when they mistakenly think it isn't capable of printing a page, merely because the UI mislead them.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by ams6110 on Saturday July 14, 2012 @12:59PM (#4244685)
I've worked directly with a number of "average" people now who moved to Chrome because it was recommended to them by somebody else, but they didn't even know about its main menu. You wouldn't believe their surprise when they see that Chrome allows them to open multiple tabs or windows, or that they can zoom the page, or that they can print.

I'll suggest that these are not things "average" users do. They don't care about tabs and windows, they just deal with them when the site they are on opens them. If they need to print something, like an order confirmation on amazon.com, they use the "Print" button that's on the page. Or they might do a screenshot if they know how to do that. And then email it to themselves.

Re:Windows 8's Achilles' heel: Metro applications by rahoulb on Saturday July 14, 2012 @11:05AM (#4244347)
But the point is people are using the computer - previously they wouldn't touch it unless they absolutely have to.

Facebook has played its part in that - but in the main computers were "those bastard machines I have to use for work" and only used under duress.