Do you really think the excess after expenses is going to wages rather than to shareholders? How can they not have enough people if they're paying £8k+ per week. Have they asked TA members if they'd take 3 weeks off work to earn a years wages?
[I read in the 'paper' theyre getting 268M for supplying 13,700 staff and that they are using some volunteers in that number]
State total cost = State front line workers' salaries + State overheads Private sector total cost = Private sector front line workers' salaries + Private sector overheads + Profit.
Overheads are everything from paddy wagons to radios to uniforms to back office staff to police horses loaned to Rebekah Brooks to the G4S CEO's £830K/year salary. Private sector firms will presumably only bid on a contract if the profit is positive, I'd agree that's a truism. But is the profit positive because the private sector total cost is higher, or because the private sector front line workers' salaries are lower, or because the private sector overheads are lower?
I think that's what rwmj wants evidence of.
It's by no means a universal truth that an investor deserves profit.
[1] http://www.out-law.com/en/articles/2012/july/special-adminis...
Where is the evidence that "cash [...] is redirected into shareholders' pockets"? This would be an ideal topic for a scientific study: do outsourced projects cost less for the buyer, or do they cost the same/more and does that extra money go to shareholders? Unfortunately reading this article will not tell you the answer to this or other interesting questions.