I think it's fine to come up with such criticism as long as it leads to looking at and questioning the result and defining further studies, but......
One of my hobbies is history and archaeology. It's what I studied mostly in college (computing was just a hobby). One of the fascinating things is that diets where the primary calories come from carbs is associated in the archaeological record with both more dental problems (due to changes in the bacterial flora of the mouth) and shorter life expectancy than are lower carb diets.
So a diet where your main sources of calories are essentially a curdled milk, and dried fish with butter, and where your primary source of carbs (and use of grain) is from beer has a longer life expectancy, and a much lower dental problem rate than a diet where grains and breads are the primary source of calories.
One of the interesting things you can watch in the Scandinavian archaeological record is that during the conversion, grain production went up, life expectancy went down,and dental caries became far more common. Moreover the spread is sufficiently high that it cannot be accounted for by infant mortality. Average life expectancy at birth in the Viking Age (according to Else Roesdahl) was approx 45, though this probably did not include infanticides which poses some selection problem. But in France at the same time it was 20. Moreover the average life expectancy at age 20 in France at the time was only 35.
This doesn't mean that there weren't other factors involved such as changing standards of hygiene, or population changes that might not have had some impact. However I don't think one can say that diet had nothing to do with it.
But you also make an interesting observation, if it has a basis in fact. It would seem to contradict the research of the Okinawan diet, which is almost exclusively plant-based, and 85% of calories are carb-derived.
1) Tooth decay rates are still the largest indications of eating a carb-based diet. These are often also used as markers for cereal agriculture, naturally enough.
2) Societies that consume excessive quantities of milk develop bone abnormalities associated with anemia, because cow's milk interferes with absorbtion of iron.
3) Societies that consume lots of fish have bones that show up as a few centuries older when run through carbon dates. This is true both for consumption of salt-water and fresh-water fish.
The doctor is right about some things. A calorie is a calorie when you are looking at weight loss. A calorie in or out s a calorie in or out. But a lot of things impact how much energy we burn, and when we are hungry and these range from when and how long we sleep[1] to what we eat.[2]
Overly simplistic/reductionist approaches don't work.[3] Chemistry is not applied quantum physics even though our understanding of chemistry is informed by quantum physics. If you are trying to help people diet, arguing that calories are what you directly control rather than the end-game is just a recipe for misery.
[1] http://www.medscape.org/viewarticle/502825
[2] For example, the effects of what we eat on insulin production are well understood, but also there are effects of insulin production on appetite that are getting more attention now. See http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16933179 for example.
[3] http://www.sciencemag.org/content/177/4047/393.full.pdf or if you don't want to pay, read it at http://www.meso2012.com/pdfs/AndersonScience177,393,72.pdf
This is not a bad thing, but it is a thing that has to be compensated.
And there is loss of water in all weight loss diets.
"the measurements were mistaken and there is not advantage from a low-carbs diet"
There is not an advantage from the calorie balancing point but there are several other aspects that are important in diets
"There is not an advantage from the calorie balancing point": what he says is that there are no advantages from a weight loss point, as the calories balance IS what creates long-term weight loss (according to him).
A diet is much more than counting calories. It's about managing to maintain a set amount of food for your objective.
Here's an experiment you can do. Replace all your food (lunch/dinner) with chicken fillets (for the daily need of protein), top up calories with sweet potatoes and olive oil for fat needs.
See how long you can keep up with this diet. This is a nutritionally sound diet (except for micronutrients), and if you calculate your daily needs you will maintain your weight (or you can adjust for weight loss or gain)
But a regular person will probably lose weight because (s)he will get sick of it fast and eat less!
The calories matter, but two things can have an equal number of calories and one may make people feel hungry after 1h and the other may make people feel full for the whole day. Guess who's more likely to lose weight?!
He says the same amount of calories are burnt. Only the relation to lean body mass (because of less water) is higher. But notice that it is just an educated guess by him, as he criticizes another study.
But you won't lose weight (meaning fat or muscle) unless there is a caloric deficit. Period
What happens is that high-protein diet changes the fullness sensation/hunger, so that's why it shows results and is easier to keep.
Of course: less grains == less fiber meaning "you may have a hard time"
Yes, a calorie is a calorie (as long as dietary: macro/micro nutrients needs are supplied), still there may be advantages to the diet, as it is pointed in the article
"They report that people on the Atkins diet were burning off more calories. Ergo, the diet is a good thing." (it's not necessarily all good especially if you think low-carb diet==eating bacon at will, still)
Also, there may be other advantages, like hunger sensation in different diets.
Dieting is calorie balancing but there are several other aspects that should be considering and dismissing 'low-carb' diets because you're only focusing on the calorie balancing is naive.