News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US “Six Strikes” Anti-Piracy Scheme Will Roll Out Gradually by bediger4000 on Friday July 13, 2012 @05:29PM (#4242052)
This makes no sense, it's like the State of New Jersey saying that the new murder law will "roll out gradually". Only some convicted offenders will be sentenced under the new law, while we work out the kinks. Eventually, all convicted murderers will be subject to the same law. That's a recipe for massive discontent, mainly because it's so unfair to those getting penalized first.

It's also very "corporate IT". "The VP wants us to phase in the new credit card processing system, because he doesn't want to lose the revenue if it crashes". The ISPs in question decided to do "pilot roll-outs" of what the techies know will be massively unpopular with the users.

Re:US “Six Strikes” Anti-Piracy Scheme Will Roll Out Gradually by noahc on Friday July 13, 2012 @10:25PM (#4242883)
I'm not sure your State analogy works. From what I can tell this is a private party agreement, which is essentially a contract. It has nothing to do with justice or laws of any sort.

You agreed that you wouldn't pirate content, when you signed up with your ISP. Your ISP has the right to terminate your service, and so this is just formalizing how that termination will take place with another party.

So what you're really saying is "Private Parties shouldn't be allowed to gradually phase in contractual agreements". I think we can all agree that regulating private contracts to this degree isn't something we want to see the US government engaged in.

Re:US “Six Strikes” Anti-Piracy Scheme Will Roll Out Gradually by bediger4000 on Friday July 13, 2012 @10:32PM (#4242892)
I'm saying that "phasing in" punitive measures, by any authority figure, under any legal or moral basis, doesn't really sit well with the population subject to those measures.

Human nature makes everyone who gets punished in an early phase very irritated by the fact that others, not subject to the early phase, but to a later phase, do NOT get punished for the same actions.

No lawyering or contractual fine points or legalistic thinking necessary.

Re:US “Six Strikes” Anti-Piracy Scheme Will Roll Out Gradually by guard-of-terra on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:35AM (#4243588)
"You agreed that you wouldn't pirate content, when you signed up with your ISP" Why? Why would your ISP care about it?

Why didn't you agree (in a contract with ISP) that you are goind to brush your teeth? That you won't troll online? That you would pay your taxes?

Because it's State masquerading as private party interests. Doing with lies what they can't do with laws.

P. S. You americans have very unusual opinion on what makes a contract and what you can put into it. Very, very unusual. And it seems that you don't even see it.