Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by tptacek on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @03:03PM
(#423859)
Quick, rattle off 3 small Twitter applications that would improve a school system. I'll start: snow days. Homework announcements. A continuous discussion with teachers and parents about curricula. Volunteering.
I'm not in love with Twitter, but the value is apparent to me: it's a social networking tool that just gets out of the way.
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by clintjhill on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @03:19PM
(#423890)
Just to be clear, I have my own project for the education space, it just isn't "twitter" like.
I don't want it to look like I'm pissing and moaning without contributing to the solution.
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by tptacek on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @03:32PM
(#423902)
I'm not saying you're goldbricking, I'm saying that you might be underestimating how far Twitter can ride the network effect.
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by diN0bot on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @04:16PM
(#423967)
that's a good point. it is also true that us geeks tend to be too into technology, rather than understanding the people and situation actually using the solution.
i don't use twitter or SMS, and i use my cell phone simply for free calling with my folks, so i don't assume that twitter apps (or cell phone apps) could help students or school administrators.
knowlege about the market is always a far more significant unknown for me than technological unknowns.
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by Angostura on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @07:15PM
(#424214)
Aren't the first too the kind of thing you can do just as well by subscribing to an RSS feed?
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by tptacek on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @08:14PM
(#424290)
From where? By setting up a blog? You lose.
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by sachinag on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @06:16PM
(#424143)
Not to derail, but a friend of mine has a "Twitter for schools" that's been getting a ton of traction - http://www.edmodo.com
(He's an IT guy at one of the suburban school districts out here, which is why he knows exactly what his users want.)
Re:Ask HN: Am I the only one tired of Twitter apps?
by michaelneale on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @06:47PM
(#424179)
>I learned that not everyone cares about "good problems". They care about "cool problems".
Exactly, and sadly true.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=417522
In my post I was speaking to the "I did this in X hours" kinds of projects I was seeing. I said there ought to be better problems to hunt down and solve. Some railed against me saying I didn't talk about big enough problems. Some said beginners ought to do things that are "quick and easy" as to gain feedback and see a project through.
I don't buy any of that. I'm going on my 10th year of software development and almost everyday I find myself feeling like a beginner. And I still see Twitter based apps finding "oops" in tweets to be a pretty big waste when our school systems can't properly share data. However I obviously haven't found a way to articulate my feelings in the best way yet.
I learned that not everyone cares about "good problems". They care about "cool problems". The good problems are the ones that are hard and may take more than 4 hours to really even understand. And probably quite longer to solve. The cool problems are much different. They aren't problems really and are mostly made up features looking for an audience.
There are many people smarter than I that will call Twitter a protocol and liken it to the next sliced bread. I look at the schools my daughters will be attending and I wonder why they can't get their crap together.