News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hubris of Front-End Developers by Zimahl on Thursday July 12, 2012 @04:55PM (#4236752)
You're saying that just because someone doesn't have a specific set of domain knowledge they can't be an 'A player' in the domain they do have knowledge in. This simply isn't true.

Using an analogy, even though Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan play golf, Michael Jordan can't be an 'A player' in basketball even though that's his domain, not golf.

Are backend developers that have only a cursory domain knowledge of the front end not 'A players'?

Re:The Hubris of Front-End Developers by xaa on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:20PM (#4236894)
A better analogy might be two different positions in basketball: shooting guard and center. To some degree, the two positions specialize: SG doesn't need to block shots (let's say), while the center does.

However, everyone needs to dribble. A simple CS concept like recursion is analogous to dribbling. If you can't dribble, you're not playing basketball. If you don't know what recursion is, you're not a professional. Period.

Re:The Hubris of Front-End Developers by fghh45sdfhr3 on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:20PM (#4236899)
Are backend developers that have only a cursory domain knowledge of the front end not 'A players'?

I would say that if have no interest in what is literally half of the internet, it does not matter how good you are at the back end, you are not an A player.

And computer science isn't just another domain. We're not talking php vs python here. This is about the fundamental nature of the work you do. Yes, even as a JS slinger, you still have the exact same computing fundamentals to deal with.

It's not like basketball and golf, it's like basic athleticism. No you can't be an A basketball player if you don't have a minimum of athleticism. And the same is true for almost all sports.

The fundamentals of computer science are to developers like cardio is to athletes.

Re:The Hubris of Front-End Developers by Zimahl on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:32PM (#4236968)
I would say that if have no interest in what is literally half of the internet, it does not matter how good you are at the back end, you are not an A player.

There are very few people who could have enough knowledge of all the domains of CS to be an 'A player' in your definition.

This is about the fundamental nature of the work you do. Yes, even as a JS slinger, you still have the exact same computing fundamentals to deal with.

Not sure if you are literally targeting me, but I am a backend developer who does a fair share of UI. I frankly despise JS but live with it nonetheless.