> (and in that scenario it would be a lot easier to frame someone by simply writing some child porn).
Well, you'd have to get some child porn to frame someone that way. Random data is much easier to procure.
Sadly not by much.
It is several orders of magnitude easier to get random data: /dev/urandom.
Re:UK anti-encryption law
by simonbrown on Thursday July 12, 2012 @09:14PM
(#4237724)
Someone wanting to frame someone else is likely prepared to put in a lot of effort anyway.
Does innocent until proven guilty and beyond a reasonable doubt apply to UK criminal law?
It is right there in the section linked from the article:
(3) For the purposes of this section a person shall be taken to have shown that he was not in possession of a key to protected information at a particular time if— (a)sufficient evidence of that fact is adduced to raise an issue with respect to it; and (b)the contrary is not proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
... which makes me sad that misinformation is being used to fight a good cause.
If someone wrote random noise to your hard drive then they couldn't prove these things (and in that scenario it would be a lot easier to frame someone by simply writing some child porn).
Encrypted files are not usually just cyphertext: there tends to be a header file with the file type, and of course there will be associated decryption software on the disk. Time and date stamps may well coincide (e.g. the decryption program was last run at the same time the suspect file was accessed). All of this would help build a case that the suspect had in fact decrypted the data in the past, and therefore could do so again.
As for steganography, they would need some clear evidence that the alleged steganographic data existed. Merely saying "maybe" and a pound will get them a cup of tea.