News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Posner: Why There Are Too Many Patents In America by PaulHoule on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:11PM (#4235256)
They aren't supposed to grant a patent if there isn't a reduction to practice. In practice, the PTO is overworked and things get through that shouldn't.

If it comes down to a lawsuit and there was no reduction ot practice, a patent can be thrown out. Of course, when it gets to court it's very expensive for everybody.

The best way to demonstrate the practicality of a software invention, for instance, is to attach working source code to the patent -- with the funny consequence that a strong software patent involves, in some sense, a contribution to open source.

Re:Richard Posner: Why There Are Too Many Patents In America by brazzy on Thursday July 12, 2012 @01:15PM (#4235516)
That's not funny or ironic, that's one of the two things patents are intended to achieve: to encourage inventions to be published for everyone to use freely (after the patent protection expires) rather than kept secret.
Re:Richard Posner: Why There Are Too Many Patents In America by PaulHoule on Thursday July 12, 2012 @04:45PM (#4236697)
it makes sense from the perspective of the patent system and it's goals, but it's contradictory to the "patents bad" attitude that is common in the open source community.