News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Try It Quiet by robconery on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:18AM (#4234919)
It was Mocha with CoffeeScript, not Ruby. It actually didn't come off "wrong to most people" - it was exactly 12 who left and didn't like it. Currently it's the second most watched video from the talk, and the organizers have told me it was in the top 5 in terms of interest and people's "choice".

Ultimately, I'm sorry you didn't like it, but it's disingenuous for you to paint it as a failure.

Re:Try It Quiet by sequoia on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:28AM (#4234995)
"It was Mocha with CoffeeScript, not Ruby."

But the point is that this wasn't clear. I thought it was neat to watch (I watched a few minutes, skipped thru) but I've used node before and write a lot of JS; if I were new to this (or if you had been, say writing Lisp or something I don't know from) it would have been very confusing. The tests thing in particular was confusing. Lesson: strings resolve to true (??).

That said I think it is a great idea to do talks more like this; I've been to talks where people go on and on about the benefits and I'm thinking "where's the beef?" But a balance would be good: x% here's how you use node y%: here's WHY you use node. The latter was missing, and the former was missing if people go slowly or get stuck on the syntax or anything.

Re:Try It Quiet by robconery on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:43AM (#4235113)
Why does it need to be clear? That is the point - I'm challenging people to think, solve, see what's happening and digest the code - and yeah I know some people won't like it. In fact I want those people to hate it. I have a sore spot with the "entitlement crowd" who need everything wrapped up sweetly with a bow - the ones who sit on their laptops in the back of the room, geek out on Twitter, and then give your talk a low rating because it was "boring slides".

Is it hard to figure out that it's CoffeeScript? I don't think so - specifically because I said that it was CoffeeScript in the beginning. You just had to read it :).

And yes! Strings resolve to true :). Madness that people got to figure that out with some code, and not a bullet point slide!

:)

Re:Try It Quiet by executive on Friday July 13, 2012 @11:09AM (#4240101)
if the talk was intro to node, then why bring Mocha and CoffeeScript into it?
Re:Try It Quiet by josteink on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:06PM (#4235229)
Ultimately, I'm sorry you didn't like it, but it's disingenuous for you to paint it as a failure.

Fair enough, but I just felt like painting another picture.

If I were to offer two core criticisms of the session (as I experienced it), it would be

1. that it got sort of repetitive after a while. 2. It was a constant stream of information, a constant stream of how, without any context, or small breaks where you got explained what just happened or what we were about to do. Lots of how. No why.

Without a "why", "how" will much more quickly turn "too much how". While these are just my 2 cents, I think there is some objective lessons to be learned at the bottom of this as well.

Still. I'll give you credit for not being a cliché at the conference. You are always willing to try something new and for that I admire you.