News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK anti-encryption law by adrianN on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:16AM (#4234910)
You can decrypt random data to anything if you want to. Say R is your random data and M is the message you want. Compute Key=R+M, then decrypt R-Key=M.
Re:UK anti-encryption law by basseq on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:35AM (#4235059)
This argument is interesting because it both a) makes the law worthless and b) removes the "scary slippery slope" argument.

After all, if you can provide a key to anything, then all you have to do (whether it's encrypted financial documents or random noise) is say, "Yep, it's encrypted, here's the key, it's the text of the Wikipedia page for 'kittens.'"

Prove that's not the correct key. If the onus for producing a key (whether one exists or not) is on the defendant, isn't the onus for proving the validity of the decrypted file on the prosecution?

All this comes back to cases like the one from CA (I think) where the guy who refused to decrypt the evidence that would prove his guilt.

And from another perspective, if you're Bernie Madoff and the evidence that will convict you is encrypted, won't you refuse to decrypt with a smile and take the 2-year punishment (with $500M in the bank) over life for financial fraud (and bankruptcy)?

Re:UK anti-encryption law by shill on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:56PM (#4235439)
This is why OTP encryption is unbreakable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_time_pad

Re:UK anti-encryption law by crusso on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:23AM (#4234948)
Assuming the encryption method can create the bit sequence that is the random data. It very well might not. There may be gaps in the encrypted data's number space.

For any non-trivial encryption method, you'd be brute forcing your way through a bunch of them to find the key that can decrypt the random noise to that message. Typical "20 times longer than the existence of the universe" warnings apply. :)

Re:UK anti-encryption law by jgeralnik on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:37AM (#4235071)
But the encryption method doesn't need to be non-trivial, especially when you define key as anything that

  (a)allows access to the electronic data, or
  (b)facilitates the putting of the data into an intelligible form;
Re:UK anti-encryption law by crusso on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:45AM (#4235123)
So, if you have a meg of random data, you're thinking you could give them a one meg XOR key that decodes it to an MP3 file of "God Save the Queen"?

Okay. :)

Re:UK anti-encryption law by MBlume on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:10PM (#4237339)
Only if you use a key the size of your data, which is not commonly done.