News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Saturday December 07, 2024 @01:47AM (#42347763)
Shouldn’t competition eliminate over billing? It doesn’t because there isn’t much competition due to lack of supply of doctors.

Why is there a lack of supply of doctors? Because the ama deliberately lobbied congress to decrease available residency.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by rich_sasha on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:57AM (#42348336)
Sometimes free market doesn't lead to competition.

UK national railway is sort of free market. The state runs the network, sells the tickets and decides the routes, but provides are chosen in open tenders - lowest price wins. They get paid for operating the route for the state-owned network.

But it then usually turns out that the only operator who can bid on the new tender for the route is the existing one. After all, they have a ready supply of trains meeting the technical spec! And if, say, the drivers go on strike demanding yet another pay rise, the providers shrug their arms and ask the state for a top up. After all, the state doesn't have an alternative either.

Free markets lead to maximizing corporate profits, but it's not a given that these correlate to a positive outcome for the society.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Saturday December 07, 2024 @09:35AM (#42350074)
Right. But doctors are regulated by government and the regulation is for a good reason but it also has bad side effects.

Doctors are not part of a free market. Supply is regulated like a cartel.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by Fluorescence on Saturday December 07, 2024 @07:35PM (#42354031)
I don't think you've got that right. There is an extra level:

Network Rail - the gov owned infrastructure, rails etc.

Rolling Stock - privately owned trains

Operators - lease rolling stock, employ staff, sell tickets

The problem we have is that the operators are barely profitable so always cutting quality/service because there is this other layer of private rolling stock company acting as landlords which are sucking all the profit out.

We have a similar problem with energy. There are the customer facing providers which are basically a brand and a call centre which are selling the power from energy generation companies. When they get trapped in some bad contract as a gamble on the energy market, they go bust.

It feels like a deliberate con that the customer facing providers, the brands the public knows about, keep going bust and earn public ire from their crap services but they are really scapegoats for a less visible layer of private company which are doing the real profiteering as landlords.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by sdenton4 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @01:53AM (#42347781)
Hard to so around for a good deal when you're bleeding out and all the prices are hidden anyway.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by rhplus on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:04AM (#42347832)
How can there be competition when no one will tell you their prices?

Pick any major city in the US and tell me how an ordinary consumer can compare prices for a simple procedure like a chest xray. It’s not possible. Now how does one shop around for a cancer doctor or an ER visit?

Medicine is not a classical marketplace. Homo economicus doesn’t play his part.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:20AM (#42347912)
How can competing doctors even afford to not tell anyone there prices if a competitor can gain a huge advantage simply by telling people there prices?

There’s not enough supply. Not enough competition such that all doctors can pull off this bs.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:22AM (#42348731)
Last time around trump mandated that all providers publish their price lists but most providers just ate the fines instead of doing it.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Saturday December 07, 2024 @09:33AM (#42350063)
Because not enough competition. The person with the cheapest price in a competitive environment obviously wants to advertise his prices.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:06AM (#42356665)
In the case where real choice is possible, yes.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Sunday December 08, 2024 @01:48PM (#42359222)
The choice is possible here. There are many doctors. Each doctor CAN display there prices. They don't want to. Why? Because there's not enough competition for them to need to.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @01:51AM (#42347774)
We also don't honor medical degrees obtained from non-US institutions. I know several folks who were doctors in India or elsewhere, who have blue collar jobs in the US because their schooling is not recognized here.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:23AM (#42348736)
Not every med school graduate matches for a residency in the US.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:38AM (#42348812)
If your point is that artificially limiting supply of trained medical personnel leads to reduced access, inflated prices, and worse outcomes overall, then I'd agree.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:44AM (#42348842)
It's a factor. I just think it would be easier to make sure there are residencies for US graduates whose training is more aligned with US Healthcare than to import foreign doctors who also require training for transition.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @06:41AM (#42349109)
I'm not sure which would be easier, or if that's even a useful measure. Both seem like points of leverage to [in/de]crease supply. I think we should do everything we can do educate, enable, and employ citizens to the highest degree of which they are capable or desire. I feel similarly about putting the talent of new immigrants to work as well, and I don't see inherent conflict there. Growing the pie can mean larger shares for all.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @07:47AM (#42349431)
Not all resources can be grown like pie, notably land. Economics is the study of scarcity.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @07:56AM (#42349479)
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:40PM (#42352719)
Not all land is equally habitable, and there's also important things like the environment. Farmland dirt wouldn't be blowing away if there was interspersed forests to slow the wind down. I'm tired of the infinite growth cultists who are willing to sacrifice every 2nd order effect so line can go up.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:19PM (#42352925)
> I'm tired of the infinite growth cultists

You sound like one of those Malthusian cultists. :P

Fortunately for us all, Thomas Robert Malthus was wrong in 1798 or none of us would be here today. That he would continue to be wrong today should be no surprise. Relevant criticism of his rather gloomy take on population growth abounds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism#Criticism

It seems to me like he didn't factor in the effects of the development and widespread application of new technologies to old problems.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:27PM (#42352982)
As an individual I'm interested in maximizing quality of life, not maximum number of lives.

And no, I am not wromg. Houston has no zoning and was able to keep growth going and build lots of new houses. Of course they did so in a flood plain. Because growth cultists are willing to sacrifice everything, even lives for growth to continue just a little longer no matter the cost.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:31PM (#42352999)
> And no, I am not wromg.

Setting your spelling aside for the moment... You haven't said anything Malthus didn't say in 1798.

I think it's fair to say standards of living have increased since.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:36PM (#42353031)
Malthus wrote about zoning?

>standards of living have increased since

Everywhere or just in some places? There are more slaves today than in malthuses time.

People usually cite the green revolution as the refutation of malthus. I see it as an engineering tradeoff. Every 2nd order effect was sacrificed for a single KPI. An economist would call them unpriced negative externalities.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:51PM (#42353117)
> Malthus wrote about zoning?

He absolutely wrote about land use and the planning thereof.

> There are more slaves today than in malthuses time.

By total number of individuals, maybe (though ChatGPT seems to think otherwise). By percentage of world population, not even close.

> I see it as an engineering tradeoff.

I see some of that. I see both negative feedback loops and virtuous cycles of positive feedback. Constructive and destructive interference. I also see an incredible explosion of education, information availability, flexible automated manufacturing, advanced material sciences, driving of food calories toward $0, lifting of disease which robbed humanity of unfathomable time and energy, and on and on. I see world solar panel production supplying world electric demand sometime in the 2030s. I see us getting better at regenerative agriculture. Mars has as much land area as Earth, and I think we can go farther if we put our minds to it.

There literally aren't limits. Except the ones we place on ourselves.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Sunday December 08, 2024 @01:55AM (#42355460)
>There literally aren't limits. Except the ones we place on ourselves.

This is the most delusional take I've ever seen. Limitations are built into the universe as entropy. No limits is only a locality mirage that exists only because you don't live long enough to see the limit get hit.

That being said air is free because it's a mirage, the sun powers plants and animals to continuously recycle it but once that source runs out then we hit a limit. As a local phenomena we can treat air as if it's free even though it's not.

But air is like one of the few things that are like this. The next thing, water, people pay for water. And people pay for water because there is a limit on it. On top of that the fact that we pay for everything else means that even as a local phenomena there are limits. If you think humanity has been on a continuous quest of breaking barriers and jumping over limitations, that's false. All humanity has been doing is optimization. Best utilizing what we already have to delay the impending termination of when humans hit the final limit.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:43AM (#42356591)
> That being said air is free because it's a mirage, the sun powers plants and animals to continuously recycle it but once that source runs out then we hit a limit.

> And people pay for water because there is a limit on it.

Both exist in massive quantity in the asteroid belt. Europa has larger oceans than Earth. Your personal financial limitations aside, I was talking about what the human race can accomplish as a whole when we set our minds to it.

> All humanity has been doing is optimization. Best utilizing what we already have to delay the impending termination of when humans hit the final limit.

Final limit? Never heard of it. Is that a band name? The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale considers a type III civilization capturing and using all of the energy emitted by an entire galaxy. And folks have proposed larger more capable civilizations yet.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:02AM (#42356640)
> Europa has larger oceans than Earth.

Then move to europa. I for one will stay here and enjoy the abundance of n-1.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by timschmidt on Sunday December 08, 2024 @08:32AM (#42357027)
> Then move to europa.

I'm sure humans or something descended from us will, in time.

> I for one will stay here

Looks like your limits are self-imposed after all.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:51AM (#42367330)
As a locality phenomenon you will not live long enough to see a time where humans mine water from space. Let’s not even get to the logistics of it.

So for all intents and purposes, water is limited for you and your limited life time.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by throwaway48476 on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:00AM (#42356635)
Well said.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by camhart on Saturday December 07, 2024 @01:51AM (#42347777)
Doctors per capita is actually up (according to wikipedia at least). So there's more Doctors available now than there used to be.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physicians_in_the_United_State....

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by alwillis on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:16AM (#42347889)
The types of doctors aren't evenly distributed—for a while there was shortage of primary care doctors.

Depending on where you live, it can take months to see a specialist.

Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by ninetyninenine on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:19AM (#42347903)
Going up doesn’t mean anything. Compare relative amounts per capita to OTHER countries.
Re:Health insurers remove executive bios, images from websit... by logicchains on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:18AM (#42347899)
It's still overall far fewer than in many other countries: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/doctors-p...