If the ads are not part of the programming, then there are 0 minutes of programming that are ads, and so 0/20 minutes of programming are ads, or 0% of the programming time is ads.
On the other hand, if you consider ads part of the programming, then there are 10/30 minutes of programming that are ads, so about 33%. (It actually closer to 8/30, but whatever.)
In no sane mathematical world does 10/30=50%. You're changing the definition of "programming" in the middle of your math, which doesn't work. You could say that the ads are "50% AS LONG as the program time", but this is different from your claim, and it's still much less clear than simply saying program to ads ratio is 2:1.
I have the word "time" after program, and the word "time" after ad.
You and the others attacking jrockway are being deliberately obtuse when it was clear what he meant. Granted, he didn't express the "claim" as accurately as one would need if programming or writing a formula on a board. But hyperbole such as "in no sane mathematical world" falls flat if you can't quote accurately yourself.
The formula you just tried to rebut was time a = 10 mins, time b = 20 mins, making a = b * .5 --quite sane.
Second, your original comment ("ads are not programming, but are as long as 50% of the programming") was correct (to the extent that the 10/30 claim is correct). My comment was not intended to say that your comment was incorrect, but that it does not change the incorrectness of jrockway's statement.
And no, it was not clear what jrockway meant. My first thought when I read that was "what the hell?". Clearly others were also confused. Attempting to justify the claim as somehow technically correct at best misguided. The simple fact is that the statement as he worded it is incorrect and (even with the twisted interpretation) misleading. As someone else pointed out, having 15 minutes of commercials does not mean that 100% of the program is commercials. This is a misleading claim, regardless of whether you can produce a convoluted interpretation to support it.
If jrockway had simply said "I spoke poorly", then I'd have much less of an issue with it. The fact that he tried to support it by heaping on with "It's one third of the total, but it's one half when added to the original." makes me think he either doesn't understand why this is incorrect (non-native speaker?), or he's intentionally pushing a misleading claim.
> The formula you just tried to rebut was time a = 10 mins, time b = 20 mins, making a = b .5 --quite sane.*
15 minutes = 15 minutes * 1, therefore 100% of the program time is commercial time. Quite sane. Or how about: You have $100 in the bank. I have $100 in my pocket. Therefore I have 100% of your money in my pocket.
I don't believe that you're actually incapable of seeing the problems with these statements, and how they are incorrect with a standard English interpretation.
The fact that you can write a formula that looks correct out of context doesn't make the claim correct. It just means your math doesn't reflect the claim accurately.
10 commercial minutes
--------------------- = ?
20 program minutesFor every two minutes of content, you pay by watching a minute of ads. Whether you call 1 minute 50% of two minutes, or call it 33% of 3 minutes, doesn't matter to his point.
However long you enjoy actual content of the show itself, you spend half again that long watching ads, and when you watch via cable, you pay for the bundle including the fee for that channel.
Then why on earth are you trying to defend the inaccurate claim?
I'd actually say it matters a great deal, because there's a huge difference between 50% and 33% (aka a 2:1 ratio and a 1:1 ratio). Especially since it's not even 2:1 in reality. It's about 2.75:1. So it's inaccuracy piled on top of exaggeration.
I don't recall saying it was a 1:1 ratio. As I recall, jrockway specified 20 minutes content, 10 minutes ads. It's plausible to call ten fifty percent of twenty, leading to his unfortunate grammar vs math, but that wasn't his point.
Btw, per Wikipedia, "a typical 30-minute block of time now includes 22 minutes of programming and eight minutes of advertisements", making it quite clear as I also used the terms, that "programming" is not "ads".
Using the wiki terminology, that's a 30 minute block of time, 22 minutes of programming, 8 minutes of ads. So, contrary to your assertion a couple comments up, programming and ads and time were the correct words, and my application of the word "time" was appropriate and accurate.
As it happens, this topic was of interest to me as I've researched ad load periodically for my work in online video delivery.
A few years ago, reality programming had 17 to 18 minutes of content and 12 - 13 minutes of advertisements, while scripted shows were consistently 22 minutes of content with 8 minutes of ads. Depending on your sampling of shows, 2:1 (20 to 10) is a reasonable average. To be fair, total ad content has gone back down a bit since.
However, it's still getting worse if you include sponsored content in the shows themselves. This link:
http://www.marketingcharts.com/television/average-hour-long-...
shows that of late night talk shows in 2009, "the combined load of brand appearances and network ad messages in these late night shows is 29m34s per hour, or 49% of total content time."
There's your 1:1 ratio! In any case, whether 33% or 49%, or "36% of an average prime-time hour", as reported above, saying that +/- 2 mins of ads undermines jrockway's double dipping claim is like an airline stewardess pushing your seat that last quarter inch forward as if it made the difference between life and death (with apologies to Seinfeld).
There are simply too many damn ads to be paying again for the privilege of being advertised to. That's why I no longer subscribe to cable (that, and half the cable bill being the particular genre of reality show called "sports", which isn't of interest to me). I spend my dollars à la carte.
TL;DR:
This link offers measured commercial time per television hour:
http://www.marketingcharts.com/television/average-hour-long-...
It says late night talk shows may have advertising "49% of total content time", while commercials are "36% of an average prime-time hour".
Right, but that's implied when someone says commercials are 50% of the programming: 1:1 ads to non-ads.
I did mistype that originally, though. I wrote "50% and 33% (aka a 2:1 ratio and a 1:1 ratio)". It should have been "50% and 33% (aka a 1:1 ratio and a 2:1 ratio)".
> As I recall, jrockway specified 20 minutes content, 10 minutes ads. It's plausible to call ten fifty percent of twenty, leading to his unfortunate grammar vs math, but that wasn't his point.
That's plausible if the context makes it clear, but it was extremely unclear in this context.
> Btw, per Wikipedia, "a typical 30-minute block of time now includes 22 minutes of programming and eight minutes of advertisements", making it quite clear as I also used the terms, that "programming" is not "ads".
Uh, how does a quote from Wikipedia make it clear what you were saying? Were we discussing a random Wikipedia page and I missed that?
> Using the wiki terminology, that's a 30 minute block of time, 22 minutes of programming, 8 minutes of ads. So, contrary to your assertion a couple comments up, programming and ads and time were the correct words, and my application of the word "time" was appropriate and accurate.
No, your application was not appropriate or accurate. Your statement's structure still implies that ads are a portion of the programming. "X is Y% of Z" implies that Z is a superset of X.
Your comment("Yet 10 mins of ads to every 20 mins of programming makes ad time exactly 50% of the program time.") says that ad time is 50% of the program time.
> saying that +/- 2 mins of ads undermines jrockway's double dipping claim
Right, but I didn't say that. I said that it was an exaggeration compounded with the misleading "50%" claim. That you're now trotting out other statistics to try to support the misstatement is irrelevant, because jrockway himself said it was 10 mins ads and 20 mins programming. He clearly wasn't talking about product placement.
I also find it strange that you're still pushing 20 to 10 as a "reasonable average" when your own reference (Wikipedia) says it's 22 to 8. Your 17-18 to 12-13 seems to be original research.
> It says late night talk shows may have advertising "49% of total content time", while commercials are "36% of an average prime-time hour".
No. That's a selective reading (and a little bit of bias pushed by the article). It says that "commercial messages" are 36% of an average prime-time hour. They included "in-show brand appearances", aka product placements, in this. As in "I can see a brand on-screen". They actually said there were about 14 minutes of "network commercial messages", or 23%; not 50%, and not even 33%. For late night, it was 26% "network commercial messages".
So then it's not 50%. It's 0%. "Hear that, HBO? Our programming has no ads at all!"
10/30 is not 50%. That's just completely broken math, and the people trying to justify the claim sound ridiculous.