Re:Introducing Mozilla Persona, An Identity System for the Web
by drcongo on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:33AM
(#4234036)
That provided a pretty confusing journey. First attempt: I clicked the Browser ID button, entered my email address on Persona, got redirected back to your site with no messaging. Tried again, it asked me to give a password this time. Did so, but then didn't redirect me back to your site. I then had to manually go back to your site and hit the BrowserID button for a 3rd time, which then took me to a Persona page to log into your site.
Re:Introducing Mozilla Persona, An Identity System for the Web
by StavrosK on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:47AM
(#4234078)
That's odd... The first time, you probably needed to verify your email, and I'm using the old API, so it doesn't sign you in right away. The second time, I don't know why it didn't log you in, I'll have to look into it...
Re:Introducing Mozilla Persona, An Identity System for the Web
by drcongo on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:04PM
(#4235217)
I'm not sure it's your issue, it seemed more like it was problem at the Persona end. Unless of course Persona was sending useful messages back to your site but your end wasn't handling them.
Re:Introducing Mozilla Persona, An Identity System for the Web
by StavrosK on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:05PM
(#4235226)
I'm not sure it's my issue either, the whole thing is pretty much plug and play using their library... It's rather old, however, there might be something they've fixed. I'll have a look and see if I can upgrade it.
Re:Introducing Mozilla Persona, An Identity System for the Web
by SCdF on Thursday July 12, 2012 @10:09PM
(#4237882)
I have to say (and this is Persona in general, not your site) the password dialogue freaks me out. I click BrowserID on your site, it opens a popup and it asks me to enter my email address, I enter one of them, and then it suddenly expects me to enter a password. Which password? My email password? On a site that isn't my email provider? Or another password? Or an existing password? Or... huh?
I think Persona really needs to sort that out, it's completely non obvious.
It always takes me 5 minutes to integrate, doesn't require me to write any sort of "forgot password" functionality, doesn't require me to worry about storing passwords, and it's generally very easy to work with.
One problem is that users don't know if they're supposed to sign up or sign in, and that a Persona works for other sites, but I think this can be ameliorated with good copy.