Re:The "simple" 38 step journey to getting an RFC
by dale_glass on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:15AM
(#42337565)
Oh hey, which Linden were you? I wonder if we met.
I used to be quite active over there. Memory is fuzzy at this point but I recall that people reverse-engineered the protocol, so I'm curious how this all fits together.
We thought it would be a simple process to publish one or two 100 page informational RFCs, get a bit of feedback and be done with it in a few months.
Two years later we had a working group and several mature internet drafts. I won't go into the drama about why the IDs never turned into RFCs, but my advice...
Never let anyone talk you into chartering a working group when all you want to do is publish an informational RFC. Also, when dealing with large multi-national companies with more lawyers and sales-people than engineers, make sure you get everything (notarized documents indicating they disclaim IP interests in the area of the internet draft) in writing first. Do not depend on them saying "hey, at the end of the process we're going to have to disclaim IP in this field anyway, so why would we lie to you?" They will wait until the last possible moment and then fail to disclaim their IP, scuttling the RFC process. I guess it's just in their nature.