News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hoare Cube by BtM909 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:07PM (#42322563)
Can someone ELI5 this, please?
Re:The Hoare Cube by aaronsnoswell on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:32PM (#42322799)
Bing Copilot's transcript from me asking it to ELI5. Take with a massive grain of salt, as it's an LLM etc. etc.

  Me: Can you please explain this webpage like I'm five!
  
  Copilot: Sure! Let’s break it down simply:
  
  The Hoare Cube: Imagine a magic cube that helps us understand how to check if computer programs work correctly or not.
  Commands and States: Think of commands as actions and states as places. When you do an action in one place, you might end up in another place.
  Hoare Triples: These are like rules that say, “If you start in a good place and do an action, you’ll end up in another good place.”
  Flipping Switches: By changing some rules (like flipping switches), you can get different ways to check if programs are correct.
  Three Dimensions:
  Reach: Can you get to a place or must you get to a place?
  Direction: Do you go forward or backward?
  Approximation: Do you guess too much or too little about what happens?
  The Cube: All these different ways of checking can be put together into a cube, showing how they relate to each other.
  It’s like a puzzle that helps computer scientists make sure programs do what they’re supposed to do!
  
  Me: Explain more about the Hoare Triples for me? That bit doesn't make sense
  Copilot: Sure! Let’s break down Hoare Triples in a simple way:
  
  What is a Hoare Triple?
  A Hoare Triple is a way to describe what a computer program does.
  It looks like this: {P} C {Q}.
  Parts of a Hoare Triple:
  P: This is the precondition. It describes what needs to be true before the program (or command) runs.
  C: This is the command. It’s the part of the program that does something.
  Q: This is the postcondition. It describes what should be true after the command runs.
  Example:
  Imagine you have a toy box (P) and you want to put a toy car in it ©. After you put the toy car in the box, the box should have the toy car inside (Q).
  In Hoare Triple terms: {Box is empty} Put toy car in box {Box has toy car}.
  Why is it useful?
  Hoare Triples help us make sure that programs do what we expect them to do.
  They are like rules that tell us if we start with certain conditions and do a specific action, we will end up with the desired result.
  Does that help clarify things?
  
  Me: So where do the hoare triples fit geometrically on this cube representation?
  Copilot: Great question! Let’s break it down:
  
  Hoare Triples: These are represented in the cube by different combinations of three dimensions:
  Reach: Whether the states can reach (may) or must reach (must) a certain condition.
  Direction: Whether the logic is forward (from start to end) or backward (from end to start).
  Approximation: Whether the behavior is over-approximated (includes all possible outcomes) or under-approximated (includes only certain outcomes).
  Cube Representation:
  Each corner (vertex) of the cube represents a different combination of these dimensions.
  For example, partial correctness is represented by the combination of may, forward, and over-approximate.
  Incorrectness logic is represented by may, forward, and under-approximate.
  Visualizing the Cube:
  Imagine a 3D cube where each axis represents one of the dimensions (Reach, Direction, Approximation).
  The corners of the cube show how different combinations of these dimensions form different types of Hoare Triples.
  Equivalences:
  Some corners are equivalent, meaning they represent the same logic but from different perspectives.
  For instance, may+forward+over is equivalent to must+backward+over.
  So, Hoare Triples fit into this cube by occupying different corners based on their specific combination of reach, direction, and approximation. This helps in understanding and comparing different program logics systematically!
  
  Me: So is "partial correctness" an example of a Hoare Triple? What is the 'P', 'C', and 'Q' in this case?
  Copilot: Yes, “partial correctness” is an example of a Hoare Triple. Let’s break it down:
  
  Partial Correctness Hoare Triple:
  {P} C {Q} means that if the precondition P is true before running the command C, and if C terminates, then the postcondition Q will be true after C finishes.
  Components:
  P (Precondition): The condition that must be true before the command starts. For example, if you’re sorting a list, P could be “the list is not empty.”
  C (Command): The action or program being executed. In our example, C would be “sort the list.”
  Q (Postcondition): The condition that must be true after the command finishes, assuming it terminates. For the sorting example, Q would be “the list is sorted.”
  Example:
  {List is not empty} Sort the list {List is sorted}.
  In the context of the Hoare Cube, partial correctness is represented by the combination of may, forward, and over-approximate. This means:
  
  May: The command may reach the postcondition.
  Forward: The logic is applied from the start to the end of the command.
  Over-approximate: The behavior includes all possible outcomes.
  This helps ensure that if the program starts in a good state (precondition) and runs correctly, it will end in a good state (postcondition).
  
  Me: So partial correctness isn't one specific hoare triple then, it's referring to a class of hoare triples that share the 'may, forward, over' properties, right?
  Copilot: Exactly! Partial correctness refers to a class of Hoare Triples that share the properties of may, forward, and over-approximate.
  
  Here’s a quick recap:
  
  May: The command may reach the postcondition.
  Forward: The logic is applied from the start to the end of the command.
  Over-approximate: The behavior includes all possible outcomes.
  So, any Hoare Triple that fits these criteria is considered part of the partial correctness class. It’s not just one specific triple, but rather a group of them that all follow these rules.
  
  Me: And I can travel between vertices of the cube by altering one of the properties I want my hoare triples to have?
  Copilot: Yes, exactly! You can move between the vertices of the Hoare Cube by changing one of the properties (reach, direction, or approximation) of your Hoare Triples. Here’s how it works:
  
  Reach:
  May: The command may reach the postcondition.
  Must: The command must reach the postcondition.
  Direction:
  Forward: The logic is applied from the start to the end of the command.
  Backward: The logic is applied from the end to the start of the command.
  Approximation:
  Over-approximate: Includes all possible outcomes.
  Under-approximate: Includes only certain outcomes.
  By changing one of these properties, you move to a different vertex on the cube. For example:
  
  If you start with partial correctness (may, forward, over-approximate) and change the reach property from may to must, you move to total correctness (must, forward, over-approximate).
  This way, you can explore different types of program logics and understand their relationships by navigating through the cube.
  
  Me: Why isn't there a point on the approximation dimension for 'no approximation'? I thought logic was an exact mathematical science?
  Copilot: That’s a great question! Let’s break it down:
  
  Approximation in Logic:
  In program verification, approximation helps us deal with the complexity of programs.
  Over-approximation includes all possible behaviors, even some that might not actually happen.
  Under-approximation includes only certain behaviors, possibly missing some that could happen.
  Why No ‘Exact’ Point?:
  Exact logic would mean capturing every possible behavior of a program perfectly, which is often impractical due to the complexity and undecidability of many program properties.
  Approximations allow us to reason about programs in a manageable way, even if it’s not perfect.
  Mathematical Logic:
  While logic is exact in mathematics, applying it to real-world programs often requires dealing with uncertainties and complexities.
  Approximations help bridge the gap between theoretical logic and practical program verification.
  So, the approximation dimension in the Hoare Cube reflects the practical need to simplify and manage the complexity of verifying real-world programs.
Re:The Hoare Cube by thechao on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:39PM (#42322851)
That's a shockingly good Socratic dialog that maps fairly well! I've not read your dialog in detail; nor have I read this blog article enough times to know if the mapping is correct. However, a quick glance shows that it's in the same ballpark!
Re:The Hoare Cube by dev-jayson on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @07:32PM (#42323581)
This is probably the longest comment I've ever seen on this platform.
Re:The Hoare Cube by aaronsnoswell on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @07:52PM (#42323696)
Downvotes - explain why?
Re:The Hoare Cube by ajb on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @08:30PM (#42323905)
Because if they wanted an LLM answer they could paste it into an LLM themselves.
Re:The Hoare Cube by CamperBob2 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:35PM (#42324661)
It's not an answer, it's a dialogue. One that's literate and erudite enough to be interesting.

Hackers aren't supposed to be knee-jerk reactionaries. Do better... or at least, vote better.

Re:The Hoare Cube by theamk on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:39PM (#42325028)
That is an answer in form of dialogue.

There is no point in engaging with LLM-generated comments, as person posting them is not an original author, you cannot ask them for clarification, discuss minor point, or point to inaccuracy. That's why LLMs are best left to personal, interactive context, and attempts to paste LLM replies into comments should be downvoted.

Re:The Hoare Cube by 73kl4453dz on Thursday December 05, 2024 @04:55PM (#42333246)
Also, ivanbakel's answer was good ; the llm one was long and unfocused.
Re:The Hoare Cube by ivanbakel on Thursday December 05, 2024 @08:34AM (#42328079)
The traditional Hoare logic is the "partial correctness" form - if the program state satisfies a precondition, and executing the program terminates with some other state, then the second state satisfies the postcondition. This is "correctness" in the sense it overapproximates all executions: if the postcondition says something about the state being "good", the precondition ensures you end in a "good" state, but perhaps there are more "good" states than actually reachable ones. It's partial because nothing is said about non-terminating executions.

A more recent idea was to flip this correctness logic to get an incorrectness logic, which says if you can reach a "bad" state (this is useful for bug detection.) In such a logic, you only want to know about reachable states, so the formula gets flipped: if the final program state satisfies the postcondition, then there must be a program state satisfying the precondition that can execute the program and terminate in that final state.

The difference between these two logics is one axis of this cube. There are other possible logics: you can ask if a precondition is necessary - that is, is the postcondition only reachable from states satisfying the precondition? It turns out there are two orthogonal approaches to stating such a property, and they form the other two axes of the cube.