News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1/0 = 0 (2018) by feoren on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:36PM (#42311799)
There's no real problem here. Infinity - Infinity is not 0; it's probably best to simply call it Infinity as well.

[ok] 1. Infinity + 1 == Infinity + 2

[ok] 2. Infinity + 1 - Infinity == Infinity + 2 - Infinity

[wrong] 3a. 1 == 2 (assumes Infinity - Infinity == 0, which is false)

[ok] 3b. Infinity == Infinity

So starting from Infinity + 1 == Infinity + 2 gets you nowhere interesting.

And that quote is a great example of what I hate about every pop-sci treatment of mathematics:

> Because infinity in mathematics isn't actually a number, it's a direction

Any time someone says "actually, in mathematics, ..." they're talking out of their ass. No matter what comes after, there is a different system of math that makes their statement false. There are plenty of branches of mathematics that are perfectly happy with infinity being a "number", not a "direction". What even is a "number" anyway?

There are no comments on this comment yet.