News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphi... by ben_w on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @03:27PM (#42310936)
While I'd agree monetisation seems to be a challenge in the long term (analogy: spreadsheets are used everywhere, but are so easy to make they're not themselves a revenue stream, only as part of a bigger package)…

> Nvidia had a revenue of $27billion in 2023 - that's about $160 per person per year [0] for every working age person in the USA

As a non-American, I'd like to point out we also earn money.

> as no AI is going to milk a cow or serve you starbucks

Cows have been getting the robots for a while now, here's a recent article: https://modernfarmer.com/2023/05/for-years-farmers-milked-co...

Robots serve coffee as well as the office parts of the coffee business: https://www.techopedia.com/ai-coffee-makers-robot-baristas-a...

Some of the malls around here have food courts where robots bring out the meals. I assume they're no more sophisticated than robot vacuum cleaners, but they get the job done.

Transformer models seem to be generally pretty good at high-level robot control, though IIRC a different architecture is needed down at the level of actuators and stepper motors.

Re:Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphi... by kimixa on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:38PM (#42311820)
Sure, robotics help many jobs, and some level of the current deep learning boom seems to have crossover in improving that - but how many of them are running LLMs that affect Nvidia's bottom line right now? There's some interesting research in that area, but it's certainly not the primary driving force. And then is the control system the limiting factor for many systems - it's probably relatively easy to get a machine today that makes a Starbucks coffee "as good as" a decently trained human. But the market doesn't seem to want that.

And I know restricting it to the US is a simplification, but so is restricting it to Nvidia, it's just to give a ballpark back-of-the-envelope "does this even make sense?" level calculation. And that's what I'm failing to see.

Re:Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphi... by amluto on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:35PM (#42312366)
Machines that will make espresso, automatically, that I personally like better than what Starbucks serves are widely available. No AI needed, and they aren't even "robotic". They can use ordinary coffee beans, and you can get them for home use or for commercial use. You can also go to a mall and get a robot to make you coffee.

Nonetheless, Starbucks does not use these machines, and I don't see any reason that AI, on its current trajectory, will change that calculation any time soon.

Re:Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphi... by lm28469 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:37PM (#42312388)
I love how the fact that we might not want AI/robots everywhere in our lives isn't even discussed.

They could serve us a plate of shit and we'd debate if pepper or salt is better to complement it

Re:Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphi... by ben_w on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:47PM (#42312495)
It's pretty often discussed, it's just hard to put everything into a single comment (or thread).

I mean, Yudkowsky has basically spent the last decade screaming into the void about how AI will with high probability literally kill everyone, and even people like me who think that danger is much less likely still look at the industrial revolution and how slow we were to react to the harms of climate change and think "speed-running another one of these may be unwise, we should probably be careful".