News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:32PM (#42310233)
> the rationale of the 2nd Amendment in the US Constitution becomes clear

About the one thing this situation does not need is armed randos taking matters into their own hands. Currently, Seoul is in a constitutional crisis. The President is required to lift martial law. He has not yet done so. If people on the streets started shooting at each other, he'd have legitimate reason to send in the military. Korea's lack of a 2nd Amendment is one of the things keeping this constitutional crisis from what would have been the stupidest civil war of the millenium.

Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by yadaeno on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:38PM (#42311826)
GP was responding to a hypothetical situation where the military does not care about the law and supports the president unconditionally. In this situation does the 2nd amendment make sense?
Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by mrguyorama on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:49PM (#42312515)
No, because by resisting at all you are already criminal, so why does it matter that you are legally allowed to own firearms when 2A supporters insist that banning firearms does not limit access to firearms?

A tyrannical state will not care that you are "legally" allowed to own firearms, and rebels do not get rights.

Also, I'll believe the claim that 2A is to prevent tyranny when I see it, because most of the time when you ask someone who supports the 2nd amendment about slave revolts, you tend to find out how little they care about "tyranny"

Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by all2 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:30PM (#42314266)
Consider the context into which the amendment was written; a very bloody war between Crown loyalists and separatists (all British subjects, mind you) had just been completed. The idea of a United States citizen was still a dream. That individuals owned and operated their own weapons was the sole reason the separatists won.

I'll point to a more recent example: the Los Angeles riots in 1992. Koreatown was protected by gun toting citizens, literally fending off the mob. (Whether we categorize the mobs as tyrannical is more pedantic than anything else, the men with weapons maintained their agency because of the threat of lethal force. Guns against a government yield the same end, maintaining agency when others may try to take it from you.)

Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by kuhsaft on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @01:18PM (#42320290)
Maybe when weapons were more limited in destruction. But, now the government has weaponry supremacy, and I don’t think you would want anybody to have access to artillery, fighter jets, etc.
Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law by Izkata on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @04:48PM (#42322392)
The second amendment refers to a well-organized militia (which requires the average person to be able to own guns), not individuals taking things into their own hands.