Re:Learn Perfect Pitch in 15 years
by qwertytyyuu on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:20PM
(#42301826)
10k hours of deliberate practise to achieve “mastery” as more of a heuristic than science
Re:Learn Perfect Pitch in 15 years
by adamgordonbell on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:23PM
(#42301850)
It's simplification of real research on expertise in a sound bite.
It's absolutely pseudoscience.
10k hours doing what? And why would we expect to see an approximately equal amount of time to achieve expertise across so many different human endeavors?
Veritasium has a really good video on the subject [0], with a much more compelling explanation for what it takes to develop expertise. He comes up with 4 things, but the two that stood out the most to me are that the field needs to be deterministic—the more randomness is involved the less expertise is possible—and that the learner needs consistent and accurate feedback on what they get right and wrong. Absent those factors no number of hours will do you any good.
BTW, is 10,000 hours not considered pseudoscience?