News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cvoss on Monday December 02, 2024 @03:43PM (#42300199)
It is argued that Bob sees light from Alice's crossing of the horizon at the same instant Bob himself crosses. Isn't this true of all matter that enters? When Bob enters, he sees everything that ever fell into the black hole "before" him, at all once? Is it blinding? Does it fry and scramble Bob? Or is it so redshifted that Bob survives?
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by kobalsky on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:17PM (#42300501)
this is my uninformed guess.

why would bob see anything? I understood that the event horizon is a threshold, not a shell that you cross and suddenly can see inside.

to see something photons have to bounce on something and reach our eyes, we stop seeing stuff inside the horizon because those photons don't bounce back and they are pulled into the singularity.

my logic said that if light can't escape the horizon, then it can't escape alice to reach bob, even if he's inside the horizon, photons can't suddenly go backwards from alice until bob, they are being pulled further inside.

Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cyberax on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:57PM (#42300859)
The objects can emit photons by themselves.

The problem is that (classically) when you cross the event horizon, the photons that you emit at just that moment will _stay_ _in_ _place_ forever.

Re:Black Hole Puzzle by raattgift on Monday December 02, 2024 @09:00PM (#42302323)
> (classically) ... photons

Uhhh... one of those words should go.

Let's keep it fully classical and drop "photon": we're interested in gravitational effects rather than quantum ones (uncertainty, fluctuations, tunnelling, details about scattering and more). Really what we want is something to illuminate (pardon the pun) interesting null geodesics, so a thin collimated beam -- a pencil of light -- will do.

The relevant surface here is the apparent horizon, which can be measured by infalling apparatuses, and not the event horizon, the location of which is determined by the configuration of the entire spacetime. (See Visser PRD 2014 <https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.90.12...> or the corresponding arxiv version <https://arxiv.org/abs/1407.7295>).

> stay in place forever

Note the region inside the shell and the downward-pointing wedge in Fig 1. of Visser 2014 is flat Minkowski spacetime. Everything in that region will work like Special Relativity, as one would expect from the shell theorem.

In particular, a pencil of light directed outwards through the apparent horizon in Fig. 1. will ride the AH down to the singularity, but a receiver intercepting the pencil of light just inside the shell would notice nothing unusual: spacetime is flat there.

Eventually the collapsing shell collides with observers floating weightlessly inside it, and they have a bad time. But they can direct a pencil of light inwards just before the shell hits them.

Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cyberax on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @08:05PM (#42323775)
I mean, we can say "electromagnetic wave" instead of a "photon". It doesn't really change much in this case.

I don't quite understand their diagram and their point. Are they looking at a region inside the collapsing shell of material? Then there's no contradiction here, the observer won't see anything until the reach the singularity (where the space-time stops being locally flat).

Even if we consider an observer in the center of the shell, they'll only encounter the singularity after they get hit by the infalling matter.

Re:Black Hole Puzzle by Sharlin on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:52PM (#42300819)
No, we're talking about images of things, photons emitted by everything that has fallen in before, before they crossed the horizon.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by mtdewcmu on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:22PM (#42300545)
I'm going to guess. From Bob's perspective, Alice's ship would still be able to block light. So he wouldn't be able to see what was ahead of him through the back of Alice's ship; Alice's ship would occlude his view.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by insapio on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:41PM (#42300732)
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cyberax on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:55PM (#42300838)
> Isn't this true of all matter that enters?

Not quite. He will see the light emitted by _all_ of the matter that has fallen in before him, but only in an infinitely small area.

Re:Black Hole Puzzle by mtdewcmu on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:11PM (#42301788)
A single photon can't be seen multiple times, right? So, if photon A goes into Alica's retina, then Bob can't see photon A. If a big, opaque object passes through the event horizon right in front of you, it would absorb or scatter the photons in its path, and you would not see them.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cyberax on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:18PM (#42301822)
Yep, I explained it a bit more here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42299891
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by mtdewcmu on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:29PM (#42301896)
So you don't see _everything_ that went in before you, mostly just the _last_ thing.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by cyberax on Monday December 02, 2024 @11:00PM (#42302975)
You'll see kind of a "cone" where the light emitted from all the objects just ahead of you can be seen, but as you look further away, you can see only more and more recent objects.
Re:Black Hole Puzzle by daxfohl on Monday December 02, 2024 @07:25PM (#42301866)
The article isn't all that great. The analysis assumes all light is emitted radially exactly outward from the center of the black hole. In reality, light is emitted in all directions, and anything emitted at even slightly different angles would get sucked into the black hole. But, you might still see it, because you can catch up with it. So when the article says you see them cross the horizon when you cross the horizon, it really means that you won't see any photons they emitted from inside the BH until you cross the BH. But similarly, one second prior you'll be encountering photons they emitted roughly 0.99 seconds prior to crossing the horizon, and so on, because those are all getting redshifted too. It's a continuous function.

There's a bit more to it than can be explained in a comment, but the main thing to know is that (as far as we know) nothing special happens at the horizon if you're falling in.