News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 06, 2009 @09:57PM (#422883)
Having gotten through this process for a Ph.D., albeit in a different field (Math), I'll answer this as best I can. My answers relate to getting a Ph.D.

1. Don't wait. Opportunity costs are low right now (bad economy) and waiting hurts your chances. If you wait at least 5 years, you are > 27 when you start grad school. You graduate at age 32. That's over the hill. Many grad schools will flatly reject you for this reason.

2. Publications might help, if they are solid technical works in peer reviewed journals. Industry experience could also help IF it's hardcore R&D work. Academics care relatively little about open source, unless you did something truly awesome (e.g., FFTW).

3. Yes. R&D type jobs are the only jobs that won't hurt you when applying to grad school.

4. GvR could probably get into a good grad school. Below that will probably not help very much.

However, many places will give you a masters if you pay tuition. Don't expect to jump from the masters to Ph.D. track, however.

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by jayp on Tuesday January 06, 2009 @10:13PM (#422905)
Hmmm, we didn't even look at age when reviewing applicants -- so I am not I sure I buy your argument that a school would "flatly reject" someone based on age. Further, I am not sure if that would be even legal (in the US).
Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 06, 2009 @11:20PM (#422997)
I know of a few departments that do it, and some professors as well (1). I'm sure not all do, but I think it's pervasive enough to worry about.

Regarding legality, I actually made a mistake when I said reject due to age. I meant reject due to having stale ideas and not appearing committed enough, or just not standing out from the crowd.

(1) Admissions process at many places: committee weeds out the weakest and professors/groups pick their students from the remainder. If a professor in your field doesn't like 30 year olds, you failed to stand out from the crowd.

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by plinkplonk on Tuesday January 06, 2009 @10:45PM (#422951)
"You graduate at age 32. That's over the hill. Many grad schools will flatly reject you for this reason"

I hope this isn't universal. I am planning to apply in 2010 and I'll be 38 when I do. Oh well one more wall to jump over, so what's new? :-)

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by whacked_new on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @02:33AM (#423139)
I recently met a first year PhD who would be very well "over the hill." Top-tier school. There's motivation for ya.

Of course, it could be an exception, but I'm sure admission was granted without respect to age. As far as I know though, luck was a big determining factor, and as such, I would look at a lot of these things (particularly if you aren't a monstrously strong candidate) very lightly.

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by plinkplonk on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @09:23AM (#423425)
"I recently met a first year PhD who would be very well o"ver the hill." Top-tier school. There's motivation for ya."

Hey Thanks!

"particularly if you aren't a monstrously strong candidate"

Good Point.

A "monstrously strong" candidate is what I am trying to be. Hey if we ask startup founders to be monstrously strong developers why not hold ourselves to the same standards as grad students. The journey is very interesting, forcing me to evaluate my deficiencies as a candidate and get better constantly.

A scientist I am working with on some research software said recently, "You'd make a great PhD student at Carnegie Mellon" (where he got his PhD) and has promised to write a reccomendation, so there's some progress. We'll see how it goes.

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by bd on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @01:57PM (#423772)
It's not that bad.

Mitch Resnick, professor at MIT Media Lab, finished his PhD when he was 36. Fourteen years after his undergraduate degree, meanwhile spending five years as a science/technology journalist for Business Week magazine.

And he has done some great research even while being older than a typical graduate student.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitchel_Resnick

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by foo23 on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @06:37AM (#423313)
Really? Surely you have figured out a more productive use of your time at 38. Phds are really good if: - you're young, have found a subject you're fascinated with and are willing to live and breathe every day or - you are absolutely sure you want to be a professor and can do top notch research

but otherwise it'll be a long time until you're able to payback the lost opportunity costs of being in grad school (no career advancement, little pay), since other than being a professor, it's unlikely having a PhD will get you any different job than before (if you're in CS).

(I was a PhD student at a top 3 cs program and left for a startup years ago)

Re:Ask HN: Getting accepted into a top level CS program. by plinkplonk on Wednesday January 07, 2009 @09:29AM (#423433)
". Phds are really good if: - you're young, have found a subject you're fascinated with and are willing to live and breathe every day"

That is exactly true for me, except obviously the "young" part :-). (But hey i feel young!)

I want to do a PhD for the experience of doing/learning to do research with top notch people and (corny as it sounds) advancing the frontiers of human knowledge. I don't really care about becoming a prof.

As for "productive", I've made enough money for me to live on comfortably, if not extravagantly , for the next twenty years. (India is a relatively cheap place to live if you have your own house and a good chunk of money saved). I am single and plan to stay that way so that obviously helps.

Research is just something I want to do (very well) before I die.