Re:Australia: Kids under 16 to be banned from social media a...
by hn_acker on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:01PM
(#42282586)
> Next, face filters are actually good for teenage self-esteem, just don't put mirrors in your house, or onlyfans... where women find the real mental glowup.
Did anyone suggest anything close to that? And why bring OnlyFans into this? This subthread [1] is about Facebook, which doesn't have face filters. Twitter doesn't have face filters. Instagram and TikTok do have face filters. Parents and guardians should be teaching children to use the internet in a healthy way, including by warning that photos on social media can be edited with internal and external tools. Some public schools already do it in health class. Removing face filters from social media sites that have them might be a good idea, but people with severe body image issues will resort to external tools and post the edited images in their group chats. But I digress.
Of the pressures that teen social media users attribute to social media, "overwhelmed because of all the drama" and "like their friends are leaving them out of things" are more prevalent than "worse about their own life" [2]; even then, most teen social media users report that social media makes them feel "more connected to what's going on in their friends' lives" and "like they have people who can support them through tough times" [3]. The percentage of teen social media users reporting that social media has had a net positive effect on them personally is greater than the percentage that report a net negative effect [3] (and the sample probably includes users of TikTok and Instagram, which have face filters).
> Written by Mike Masnick.....
Including a public infographic from Facebook's internal research [4], followed by infographics and excerpts from Pew Research, yes.
Also, I have to correct what I wrote in my previous comment.
> Facebook's internal documents showed that on 11 of 12 body image issues, Facebook was helpful to more teens than it was harmful to
The infographic I was referring to as evidence was from a public excerpt from Facebook's internal research, not from internal documents. The infographic was about Instagram, not Facebook. Instagram, which has an app with face filters. The corrected version of what I wrote is:
< Facebook's public statement on an internal study showed that on 11 of 12 body image issues, Instagram was helpful to more teens than it was harmful to
Did anyone suggest anything close to that? And why bring OnlyFans into this? This subthread [1] is about Facebook, which doesn't have face filters. Twitter doesn't have face filters. Instagram and TikTok do have face filters. Parents and guardians should be teaching children to use the internet in a healthy way, including by warning that photos on social media can be edited with internal and external tools. Some public schools already do it in health class. Removing face filters from social media sites that have them might be a good idea, but people with severe body image issues will resort to external tools and post the edited images in their group chats. But I digress.
Of the pressures that teen social media users attribute to social media, "overwhelmed because of all the drama" and "like their friends are leaving them out of things" are more prevalent than "worse about their own life" [2]; even then, most teen social media users report that social media makes them feel "more connected to what's going on in their friends' lives" and "like they have people who can support them through tough times" [3]. The percentage of teen social media users reporting that social media has had a net positive effect on them personally is greater than the percentage that report a net negative effect [3] (and the sample probably includes users of TikTok and Instagram, which have face filters).
> Written by Mike Masnick.....
Including a public infographic from Facebook's internal research [4], followed by infographics and excerpts from Pew Research, yes.
Also, I have to correct what I wrote in my previous comment.
> Facebook's internal documents showed that on 11 of 12 body image issues, Facebook was helpful to more teens than it was harmful to
The infographic I was referring to as evidence was from a public excerpt from Facebook's internal research, not from internal documents. The infographic was about Instagram, not Facebook. Instagram, which has an app with face filters. The corrected version of what I wrote is:
< Facebook's public statement on an internal study showed that on 11 of 12 body image issues, Instagram was helpful to more teens than it was harmful to
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42266581
[2] https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2022/11/16/connection-c...
[3] https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2022/11/16/connection-c...
[4] https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Instagram-Te...