Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by Lerc on Saturday November 30, 2024 @07:49AM
(#42281298)
That seems a bit of an odd definition.
A: Doing it with B.
B: Using C to do it.
C: The part that does B
Without defining, "Your", "Consider", "person", "thinking", "feel", and "understand" it could be anything.
There's more than enough leeway in those undefineds to subjectively choose whatever you want.
Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by nuancebydefault on Saturday November 30, 2024 @12:42PM
(#42282883)
I would rather call it circular reasoning,a thing humans are very capable of.
Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by dboreham on Saturday November 30, 2024 @09:54AM
(#42281933)
Enter the Chinese Room..
Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by jb_briant on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:30PM
(#42283476)
What do you mean please?
Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by whitten on Saturday November 30, 2024 @03:33PM
(#42283848)
The Chinese Room is a theoretical room that contains a “Chinese speaker” but actually when given a text to ‘understand’ actually just looks up the text in a huge number of words inside until it finds a way to find a response and then just outputs the response as its reply
Re:DeepThought-8B: A small, capable reasoning model
by andai on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:28PM
(#42283152)
>I conclude that "An algorithm that searches for the highest probability answer" is not described by "reasoning"
I recall reading about a theory of neurology where many thoughts (neural circuits) fired simultaneously and then one would "win" and the others got suppressed. The closest thing I can find right now is Global Workspace Theory.
Reasoning "the process of thinking about something in order to make a decision"
Thinking: "the activity of using your mind to consider something"
Mind: "the part of a person that makes it possible for him or her to think, feel emotions, and understand things"
I conclude that "An algorithm that searches for the highest probability answer" is not described by "reasoning"
I also think that the definition of Mind of Cambridge is incomplete and lacks the creativity part along with cognition and emotions. But it's a vastly different topic.