Mongrel was always pretty solid actually. It was originally developed for verisign as I recall, and even in its early versions stuck much more closely to the http specs than other webservers.
It caught a lot of flack because of application code blasting out the ruby heap by touching too many objects. Mongrel isn't really to blame for that. With early versions of ActiveRecord it was easy to materialize large result sets without realizing it. A lot of people felt the pain of using associations everywhere without thinking about what would happen when the joins would go north of 10k objects. Not really mongrel's fault.
Still, the guys over at Twitter could have said "We couldn't scale this technology given our requirements and current knowledge so we went with what we are comfortable with, and thats Java." Instead, they blamed Rails. And now any Rails hater brings up Twitter in a flame war. Even though it was some 4-5 years ago.