News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Not React, Then What? by jmye on Saturday November 30, 2024 @01:03AM (#42279889)
Do you not care about most of your potential customers, or do you only cater to high net worth people? If so, then sure, substandard devices and connections can be ignored. If you’re Target, on the other hand, you probably shouldn’t ignore them.

I find it extremely odd that this was even a question on this site. Do you think the problem you’re solving should impact your tech stack at all, or is your tech stack more important than the problem?

Re:If Not React, Then What? by refulgentis on Saturday November 30, 2024 @11:38AM (#42282447)
You're making the same mistake as the author. I get unnecessarily aggro too, but a plain reading of their comment isn't "they only cater to high net worth people" or they're advocating for such. Its "hey we're talking about 3G connections at this point, which are mostly shut down, and we don't cover developing markets"
Re:If Not React, Then What? by Spivak on Saturday November 30, 2024 @02:41PM (#42283539)
I keep hearing the "SPA is actually lightweight" argument but it's never materialized for me, the fastest sites are SSRs that are mostly static. The saving from HTML vs JSON just isn't that much over the wire and mobile CPUs and memory are a bottleneck.

I have a newer iPhone and Safari is still full-refreshing pages constantly due to memory.

Re:If Not React, Then What? by refulgentis on Saturday November 30, 2024 @06:54PM (#42284967)
> "SPA is actually lightweight"

With utmost respect, that's not what I'm saying :)

I hold no hot take position on anything web dev, or any firm declarative position.

What I'm trying to get at is, indicia of an article being half-baked includes things like asserting all that's required to agree is to care about the user.

This feels good to say, but doesn't say anything, other than there's been at least some short-circuiting of thought. We can come up with many trivial cases where "caring about users" involves requiring client-side logic during rendering.