For example, let's say instead of gradient descent you want to do a Newton descent. Then maybe there's a better way to compute the needed weight updates besides backprop?
The important thing is backprop does work and so we're just scaling it up to absurd levels to get good results. There is going to be a big step change found sooner or later where training gets a lot better. Maybe there is some sort of threshold we're looking for where a trick only works for models with lots of parameters or something before we stumble on it, but if evolution can do it so will researchers.
IIRC, feedback alignment [1] approximates Gauss-Newton minimization. So there is an easier way, that is potentially biologically more plausible, though not necessarily a better way.
Agreed on both counts. There's nothing surprising in "there are differences between the brain and ANN's."
But their might be something useful in the "novel theory about how the brain solves the credit assignment problem" presented in the paper. At least for me, it caught my attention enough to justify giving it a full reading sometime soon.
Dang it, how did I miss that. Uugh. :-(
There are no words in the title which express this. Your own brain is "making it sound" like that. Misleading, yes, but attribute it correctly.
The angle I actually see in it though is the typical pitiful appeal to the idea that the brain is this incredible thing we should never hope to unravel, that AI bad, and that everyone working on AI is an idiot as per the link (and then the link painting a leaps and bounds more nuanced picture).
1. both ANNs and the brain need to solve the credit assignment problem 2. backprop works well for ANNs but probably isn't how the problem is solved in the brain
This paper is really interesting, but is more a novel theory about how the brain solves the credit assignment problem. The HN title makes it sound like differences between the brain and ANNs were previously unknown and is misleading IMO.