News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Is it just me, or is CarPlay unusable?

Sorry for the rant, but it's also a question. Tried an iPhone 5, 6, 6S, X, and 12. Tried Honda, Nissan, Toyota, GM, Chrysler, Ford, and aftermarket systems, some rented and a couple my own cars. Tried wired and wireless. Tried this across the years since it came out. And I'm bringing this up now because it failed me again with my brand new Honda.

Every single time I've used it, something either small or big has gone wrong. I could list it all, but here are the two biggest ones that made me disable it:

1. Apple Maps freezes occasionally until I kill/reopen the app. Usually it's ok, but each time I give it another chance, one day it freezes on a random straight road and I miss several turns before I notice. So I can't trust it. I don't use Google Maps enough to see if this happens there, but part of that is because it often centers my arrow weirdly on CarPlay only.

2. Basic music playback feels like it's transcoded in pure JS or something. Sometimes it hiccups, sometimes it stops, one time it even played distorted sound (and yes I tested the FM radio to make sure it wasn't just the sound system). Skipping songs consistently takes like 3000ms on this car at least.

Whenever I complain about this somewhere, I'm told that it works great for everyone else, my car is bad, my phone is old, I'm holding it wrong, whatever. No, I'm almost certain this feature is just broken, either on Apple's end or on every single car manufacturer's end. Meanwhile aux or even BT audio works fine, and I just use my phone on a vent holder. Am I missing something? Was I supposed to buy an iPhone 16 Pro Max along with a Ferrari 296 to ensure I have the latest in hardware-accelerated song-skipping?

( 4 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:Is it just me, or is CarPlay unusable? by jheuel on Monday November 25, 2024 @02:41AM (#42234070)
No problems here. I use YouTube Music or the Podcasts app for audio and Apple Maps or Google Maps to navigate (prefer Apple Maps because it pauses Podcasts while talking). Always wired and mostly in German cars: I tried VW, BMW, Mercedes, Opel and Suzuki.
Re:Is it just me, or is CarPlay unusable? by hot_gril on Monday November 25, 2024 @02:46AM (#42234096)
Those are a couple of differences, I've never tried in a German car and typically use either the built-in Music app or sometimes in-browser YouTube.
Re:Is it just me, or is CarPlay unusable? by mPReDiToR on Monday November 25, 2024 @02:36AM (#42234035)
I'm a professional driver and have been since the 90s.

The day will one day come where the shitty proprietary map providers that pay auto manufacturers to foist them on us get ousted and we can have a USB-C connection to the car's system display for our screen mirroring as standard.

In-vehicle audio and navigation is utterly useless. Costly updates, unfamiliar GUI's, distracting bells and whistles.

There are two SatNav's I've seen used by colleagues:

GOOG maps (thanks for messing up timeline last week, shitheads)

TomTom trucks (I drive large vehicles these days)

I'd love to have a screen that mirrors my phone, on the dash, not obscuring the windscreen, with connections to the steering wheel controls and the speakers.

Making do with a vent/suction holder is frustrating.

Re:Is it just me, or is CarPlay unusable? by hot_gril on Monday November 25, 2024 @02:39AM (#42234050)
I do notice how every Uber driver has the vent holder.