Re:DC "Uber Amendment" would force sedans to charge 5x more ...
by yummyfajitas on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @10:35AM
(#4223975)
A monopoly is a market with only one supplier.
Pepsi and Coke are not a monopoly - as you explicitly acknowledge, there are at least two suppliers in this market.
Microsoft was never a monopoly, there were always other suppliers (Sun, Be, IBM, Apple, Linux, at different points in time).
Re:DC "Uber Amendment" would force sedans to charge 5x more ...
by drostie on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @03:55PM
(#4225809)
That's why I was putting more emphasis on the word "domination" than on "monopoly". I agree that WalterBright may have been making a very dense and mostly irrelevant point, to which the proper response may have been "so what?". I simply disagree that this is how we should interpret it. Rather I would give the benefit of the doubt and take him as making a real, germane, substatial-but-misguided libertarian talking point. That is, there are legitimately people in the libertarian camp (I was one of them!) who falsely conflate deregulated markets and competitive ones.
I would go so far as to say: governments themselves are "free-market monopolies" in this sense. That is, there is no binding unilateral authority which solves intergovernmental disputes, and each government instead has to negotiate with other governments in an open and unregulated forum where even backstabbing and flagrant contract violations are permitted. If governments are monopolies on power, then the market of power is surely not a well-regulated one.