News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Betting the Company on Windows 8 by batiudrami on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:54PM (#4221411)
You have to be kidding me. Discoverability is lower in a system which uses logically arranged tools, with larger buttons for more frequently used options than in a system which, perplexingly, hides everything behind nonlabeled buttons, in menus and sub-menus and ridiculous dialog boxes?

The ribbon is a massive, massive step up in usability, the difference is you already knew how to get to features in the old version, so there was a learning curve. Show two people who are brand new to office Office XP vs Office 2010, and I an completely certain that they'll have an easier time with 2010 (especially Excel, the usability difference there is incredible).

Re:Betting the Company on Windows 8 by xtracto on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:00PM (#4221633)
>Discoverability is lower in a system which uses logically arranged tools, with larger buttons for more frequently used options.

Sure, if you use the "more frequently used options" but try using something a bit more obscure and you are out of luck.

At least with the menu system you had those "breadcrumbs" to give you an idea of where it could be.

Re:Betting the Company on Windows 8 by mindcrime on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @02:18PM (#4225274)
Discoverability is lower in a system which uses logically arranged tools, with larger buttons for more frequently used options than in a system which, perplexingly, hides everything behind nonlabeled buttons, in menus and sub-menus and ridiculous dialog boxes?

If you're trying to do anything other than the obvious stuff, then yes. I struggle to find anything in Office w/ Ribbon, whereas I could almost always find what I was looking for in a few seconds worth of menu hunting before. Personally, I find discoverability to be absolute shyte with the Ribbon interface.