Re:ICC issues warrants of arrest for Benjamin Netanyahu and ...
by YZF on Friday November 22, 2024 @01:32AM
(#42211621)
I'm not sure what "deliberately withheld food and medicine from civilians in a calculated manner" means exactly.
Did the US, UK, and Australia supply the citizens of the Islamic State with aid as they were attacking them?
Did the Syrian government and the Russians supply the cities they were barrel bombing with food?
Do the Turkish supply the Kurds they're bombing with aid?
Did Israel prevent aid coming in from Egypt? Generally no. Israel did request Egypt to let it check the trucks that go in but that was not the bottleneck. Every time international organizations screamed about hunger in Gaza there was plenty of evidence that there was a lot of food (markets were full of food). Population that refuses to evacuate, stays in fighting zones, can't expect to have Pizza delivered to their door but a lot of effort went into supply those areas as well. Which is really unprecedented in any war.
Right now Egypt refuses to deliver aid through the Rafah crossing because Israel took the Gaza side of it. What about the stocks the Gaza government (Hamas) held, did those get disbursed to the civilians? Why is this all on Israel?
You seem to have a very flexible definition for a war crime.
The problem is that this starts with the politics. Only through a certain political prism does this look like a war crime. The court makes many political assertions and under that distorted lens Israel somehow has to feed the enemy while that enemy is actively fighting them, stealing the aid, and cares nothing if their own people starve or not. Really Israel is not allowed to wage war with Hamas because it's embedded with civilians is about it. This is not what international law says, this is political twisting of that law.
Did the US, UK, and Australia supply the citizens of the Islamic State with aid as they were attacking them?
Did the Syrian government and the Russians supply the cities they were barrel bombing with food?
Do the Turkish supply the Kurds they're bombing with aid?
Did Israel prevent aid coming in from Egypt? Generally no. Israel did request Egypt to let it check the trucks that go in but that was not the bottleneck. Every time international organizations screamed about hunger in Gaza there was plenty of evidence that there was a lot of food (markets were full of food). Population that refuses to evacuate, stays in fighting zones, can't expect to have Pizza delivered to their door but a lot of effort went into supply those areas as well. Which is really unprecedented in any war.
Right now Egypt refuses to deliver aid through the Rafah crossing because Israel took the Gaza side of it. What about the stocks the Gaza government (Hamas) held, did those get disbursed to the civilians? Why is this all on Israel?
You seem to have a very flexible definition for a war crime.
The problem is that this starts with the politics. Only through a certain political prism does this look like a war crime. The court makes many political assertions and under that distorted lens Israel somehow has to feed the enemy while that enemy is actively fighting them, stealing the aid, and cares nothing if their own people starve or not. Really Israel is not allowed to wage war with Hamas because it's embedded with civilians is about it. This is not what international law says, this is political twisting of that law.