News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by dismalaf on Thursday November 21, 2024 @02:16AM (#42201905)
This is the thing though. Non-Apple phones are made of equally nice materials, have equally nice design and equal or more utility. Several Samsung phones and the folding Pixel are more money than the top end iPhone. Hell, because of carrier subsidies the top end iPhone can be had for $0 up front.

So what makes an iPhone more luxurious than say, a Galaxy S24 Ultra, Z Fold 6, Pixel 9 Pro XL or 9 Pro Fold?

Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 21, 2024 @02:18AM (#42201913)
> Non-Apple phones are made of equally nice materials

The machine quality is totally different.

> what makes an iPhone more luxurious than say, a Galaxy S24 Ultra, Z Fold 6, Pixel 9 Pro XL or 9 Pro Fold

Start with the BOM.

Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by dismalaf on Thursday November 21, 2024 @02:58AM (#42202094)
Lol so it's the logo and marketing. Gotcha.
Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 21, 2024 @04:29AM (#42202538)
I mean yes, that’s a big part of what distinguishes luxury goods. Again, luxury doesn’t mean better.

When I say machine quality, though, I’m referring to their titanium and aluminum. I’ve machined some aluminum and know people who have done titanium. It’s really hard, and they do it well.

What does that add to the user experience? I can’t say it’s anything tangible. But I appreciate it. That’s luxury. It’s orthogonal to utility in many ways.

Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by whatisthiseven on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:58AM (#42204341)
I think when you say "luxury goods" you mean to say Veblen Goods, which are about signaling wealth or status through the purchase of a particular brand. When the functions of a good are divorced from its price and the brand is what defines "the luxury", it ceases to signal quality and instead is a signal all its own.
Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 21, 2024 @10:41PM (#42210964)
> when you say "luxury goods" you mean to say Veblen Goods, which are about signaling wealth or status through the purchase of a particular brand

No, I mean luxury good. I upgraded my phone for satellite-based emergency SOS and the titanium form factor. Those are luxuries. Same for my 2020 Mac and M1.

Apple’s products aren’t priced high enough to function as Veblen goods in most developed-country social circles. They’re a mass market product.

Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by dismalaf on Thursday November 21, 2024 @10:42AM (#42205441)
I know you're referring to the materials. And I'm saying you can find those same materials in Android phones.

I'm used to actual luxury goods, watches and clothing for example, where the quality is very much noticeably better. A Rolex or Audemars has way more attention to detail than, say, a Tissot or Tag which has far nicer materials than a Timex. Or suits, the kinds of fabric on higher end suits are very noticeable.

Or luxury restaurants. Where the ingredients, techniques, staffing levels and attention to detail far surpass normal restaurants.

Whereas with iPhone versus Samsung S24 Ultra, both are titanium, Samsung has nicer glass, less bevel and more utility (also costs more). The only real difference is Apple has much better marketing and their stores are nicer. Better logo too. Beyond that, there's no quantifiable quality advantage.

Re:Apple fights to keep DOJ antitrust suit from reaching trial by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 21, 2024 @10:44PM (#42210982)
> I'm used to actual luxury goods

Yes. Me too. We’re rich and accustomed to luxury on HN. News at 11.

I don’t like the S24. Part of that is familiarity with iOS, which makes Android’s interface and design language feel clunky. Part of that is the squared-off look. I don’t deny that it’s a luxury product, too.

> Rolex or Audemars

Good example. I know plenty of watch connoisseurs who don’t believe Rolex makes a luxury product. They use similar arguments to yours, down to details of the movement and price. I think they’re wrong on designation even if I, too, don’t like Rolex either. (Patek and Vacheron Constantin.)