News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by llm_trw on Monday November 18, 2024 @06:10PM (#42178187)
A cluster is not a super computer.

The whole point of a super computer is that it act as much as a single machine as it is possible while a cluster is a soup of nearly independent machines.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by kristjansson on Monday November 18, 2024 @06:15PM (#42178234)
> soup of nearly independent machines

that does a serious disservice to hyperscaler clusters.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by llm_trw on Monday November 18, 2024 @07:20PM (#42178817)
Sure but it's closer to the truth than saying they have similar or more raw compute than a super computer.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by almostgotcaught on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:09PM (#42179465)
i wish people wouldn't make stuff up just to sound cool.

like do you have actual experience with gov/edu HPC? i doubt it because you couldn't be more wrong - lab HPC clusters are just very very poorly (relative to FAANG) strewn together nodes. there is absolutely no sense in which they are "one single machine" (nothing is "abstracted over" except NFS).

what you're saying is trivially false because no one ever requests all the machines at once (except when they're running linpack to produce top500 numbers). the rest of the time the workflow is exactly like in any industrial cluster: request some machines (through slurm), get those machines, run your job (hopefully you distributed the job across the nodes correctly), release those machines. if i still had my account i could tell you literally how many different jobs are running right now on polaris.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by bocklund on Monday November 18, 2024 @10:01PM (#42179716)
Actually, LLNL (the site of El Capitan) has a process for requesting Dedicated Application Time (a DAT) where you use up to a whole machine, usually over a weekend. They occur fairly regularly. Mostly it's lots of individual users and jobs, like you said though.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by almostgotcaught on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:18AM (#42180282)
> where you use up to a whole machine

i mean rick stevens et al can grab all of polaris too but even so - it's just a bunch of nodes and you're responsible for distributing your work across those nodes efficiently. there's no sense in which it's a "single computer" in any way, shape or form.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by llm_trw on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:30AM (#42180326)
The same way that you're responsible for distributing your single threaded code between cores on your desktop.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by davrosthedalek on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:29AM (#42182694)
No. Threads run typically in the same address space. HPC processes on different nodes typically do not.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by llm_trw on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:00AM (#42183490)
Define address space.

Cache is not shared between cores.

HPCs just have more levels of cache.

Lest you ignore the fact that infiniband is pretty much on par with top of the line ddr speeds for the matching generation.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by moralestapia on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:08PM (#42185697)
>Lest you ignore the fact that infiniband is pretty much on par with top of the line ddr speeds for the matching generation.

You can't go faster than the speed of light (yet) and traveling a few micrometers will always be much faster than traversing a room (plus routing and switching).

Many HPC tasks nowadays are memory-bound rather than CPU-bound, memory-latency-and-throughput-bound to be more precise. An actual supercomputer would be something like the Cerebras chip, a lot of the performance increase you get is due to having everything on-chip at a given time.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by formerly_proven on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:29AM (#42185261)
There are four sentences in your comment.

None of them logically relate to another.

One is a question.

And the rest are wrong.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by davrosthedalek on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:13AM (#42183627)
Really? How about: "This pointer is valid, has the same numeric value (address) and points to the same data in all threads". The point is not the latency nor bandwidth. The point is the programming/memory model. Infiniband maybe makes multiprocessing across nodes as fast as multiprocessing on a single node. But it's not multithreading.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by imtringued on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:49AM (#42184007)
>Cache is not shared between cores.

I feel sorry for you if you believe this. It's not true physically nor is it true on the level of the cache coherence protocol nor is it true from the perspective of the operating system.

Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by almostgotcaught on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:23AM (#42183140)
Tell me you've never run a distributed workload without telling me. You realize if what you were saying were true, HPC would be trivial. In fact it takes a whole lot of PhDs to manage the added complexity because it's not just a "single computer".
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by llm_trw on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:49AM (#42183388)
If you think parallelizing single threaded code is trivial ... well there's nothing else to say really.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by almostgotcaught on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:59AM (#42183483)
Is there like a training program available for learning how to be this obstinate? I would love to attend so that I can win fights with my wife.
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by davrosthedalek on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:39PM (#42187852)
Maybe llm_trw is your wife?
Re:AMD Now Has More Compute on the Top500 Than Nvidia by bravetraveler on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:57AM (#42180953)
Put slurm on it, bam. Supercomputer.