Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by antves on Monday November 18, 2024 @01:20PM
(#42175255)
I think the main bit here is that the knowledge graph is entirely constructed by LLMs. It's not just using a pre-existing knowledge graph. It's creating a knowledge graph on the fly based on your data.
Navigating the graph, on the other hand, is the perfect task for PageRank.
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by liukidar on Monday November 18, 2024 @01:24PM
(#42175322)
Exactly! Also PageRank is used to navigate the graph and find "missing links" between the concepts selected from the query using semantic search via LLMs (so to be able to find information to answer questions that require multi-hop or complex reasoning in one go).
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by dartos on Monday November 18, 2024 @01:38PM
(#42175455)
Makes perfect sense.
The semantic understanding capabilities fit well for creating knowledge graphs.
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by IanCal on Monday November 18, 2024 @02:12PM
(#42175811)
I don't get what the irony is here.
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by chefandy on Monday November 18, 2024 @02:31PM
(#42175998)
Not who you're replying to, but from my vantage point, marketing folks seem to be pushing LLM products as replacements for traditional search products. I think what the post is proposing makes perfect sense from a technical perspective, though. The utility of LLMs will come down to good old-fashioned product design, leveraging existing concepts, and novel technical innovation rather than just dumping quintillions of dollars into increasingly large models and hardware until it does everything for us.
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by dartos on Monday November 18, 2024 @03:41PM
(#42176743)
Exactly this.
I work in the LLM-augmented search space, so I might be a little too tuned in on this subject.
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by mdp2021 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:15AM
(#42184293)
What you should note as quaint is probably more like the integration of more "symbolic" strategies to NNs in AI.
Past the initial sensation, it is pretty linear that "something good at language" (an interface) be integrated with "something good at information retrieval" (the data). (Still sought what comes next, "something to give reliability to processing".)
Re:Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
by mehh on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:07PM
(#42186981)
It’s not AI, it’s a collection technologies and practices within the domain of AI, symbolic and sub symbolic. Arguably classic search is another technology/approach/algorithm with the domain of AI.
Obviously LLMs are good at some semantic understanding of the prompt context and are useful, but the irony is hilarious