I didn't even give IIT JEE, just CET. And at end of the year I had something like several 10s of kgs of paper on which I had practiced math, physics and chemistry. I was forced to beat the exams into my submission.
Those kids go into IIT's to get good jobs, so that they end up like their parents doing small time jobs. To buy homes, cars, to 'become something in life'.
Folks can solve all the math problems they want.It has nothing to do with creating a good product and selling it.
And trust me such students make it big. Just because they work for start ups, it doesn't mean they don't make it big.
>>Seems like you went on your own sweet tangent.
I don't see what is wrong with it. Do you have a problem?
It's a process of experimentation, constant observation, accumulating knowledge and forging ahead on your own with very little external encouragement.
If you told me IIT kids spent countless hours experimenting and tinkering with their own projects, then it'd be a different story.
But the test prep process for IIT JEE/AIEEE is a very pre-defined route, that EVERYONE is doing, with lots of encouragement from parents and a soul-killing process of cramming - for the singular goal of passing tests set up by a very bureaucratic establishment.
It sounds like the opposite of the preparation needed for risk aversion and creative endeavors.
Personally I flunked IIT Mains because with my ADHD I could not get myself to study more than a few hours every week.Also at the ripe age of 17-18 I did not have enough drive or ambition to stop doing the things kids love to do (chasing girls, watching movies, loafing around etc etc.) But then I am actually proud that I did not give in to the IIT bullshit and did whatever I wanted to do. You will never get that age back no matter how successful you are!
But what I wanted to say was, traditionally Indian entrance exams have always been soul crushing. Take IAS or CA for example. You practically have to give your whole youth/teenage to make it happen.
Indian civil services are known to be one of the most grinding and testing exams in the world.
Okay that might have sounded a little mean.Sorry having a pretty tiresome day :)
Also, a Godel prize was won in this decade at IITK (for AKS) and (not sure about this) Niraj Kayal (the K in AKS) began working on this during his undergrad years.
I didn't graduate from an IIT (different continent) but my friends from there executed very well in their internships, theses, grad school applications, papers etc. Talent is not geographically bound and to a certain extent JEE performance correlates with good reasoning and math skills (universally transferable in engineering at least).
Confession: I did not ask one either, as I was not as well aware of the latest developments. I questioned the next presenter though who talked about the Spoken Tutorial. And it was the only question asked.
[1] http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/167/aakash-tablet-india-...
Anyway that was offtopic. The IITs have a very high average IQ that manifests itself well in the form of publications and the accomplishments of the alumni/students/faculty - they are definitely not "education factories" and an engineering degree from there is very respected. Pitting them against institutions with endowments in excess of 8bn is unfair.
There's a cultural divide in the US between large companies and startups; startup people tend to be more inquisitive, more self-directed, and more willing to challenge authority. The Indian teams I worked with struck me as being like a US large company team, but even more so. Nobody would ask questions or challenge assumptions, especially in group contexts.
I don't know why that was, but with US large-company teams it's because they're reluctant to risk looking dumb in front of people with power. Or worse, to make the people with power look dumb. They are more likely to value obedience over being correct or having a successful project. Basically, they are very focused on keeping their jobs.
Besides when you do well no one appreciates, but when you do something wrong every one comes after you.
This is a problem with large teams in general and has nothing to with Indians or Americans in general.
I did meet Prof. Phatak, asked him many questions and he answered my questions as well.
Please have a look at project E-Yantra as well. http://www.e-yantra.org/ and http://portal.e-yantra.org/
It is a good project.
The only reason I took my questions offline was because they were pretty hard ones and I dint want to be painted as a troll.
Some projects might not be that great as some startups aren't that great. Again, you should not be judging looking at a single project.
And IITians love to find the answer to their questions themselves :)
I know people will cite remittances, but those are pittance compared to getting your hands dirty and building assets for your own society.
I recently attended the Ubuntu launch event at the Mumbai's IIT and Dr Phatak, who now heads India's cheap tablet project did a talk. To my surprise, there was not even one question from the audience of bright IIT students.
They also have poorly executed projects like "Spoken Tutorials" http://spoken-tutorial.org/ that were presented and it was all very depressing.
I would not expect good quality startups from IITs.