Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by mezzie2 on Friday November 15, 2024 @08:25AM
(#42146706)
Or if you have to talk to a visually impaired person. My vision impairments are on the very mild end of the spectrum, but they're still enough to prevent any effective use of or learning of sign.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by zie on Friday November 15, 2024 @11:50AM
(#42148577)
See tactile signing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactile_signing
Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by bluGill on Friday November 15, 2024 @10:23AM
(#42147711)
I have "met" people who are both blind and deaf. They use sign language by putting their hand on the hand of the signer and follow that way. (I only know a couple signs so it wasn't worth trying to talk to them except via interpreter and so saying I've met them is a bit strong)
This also is proof that sign language works in the dark.
Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by mezzie2 on Friday November 15, 2024 @10:56AM
(#42148036)
ASL (and sign language generally) and tactile sign are two different languages, and language types that are at least as different as verbal languages and seen/sign languages - an American deafblind person who uses tactile sign and meets someone who uses ASL isn't necessarily going to be able to communicate with them. The signs and underlying language structure (morphology/syntax/etc.) are all different. I wouldn't consider the existence of tactile sign to mean that sign language works in the dark because they're two different language types, but the terminology is confusing and I have a linguistics background so I don't know if the author was including tactile sign or not. I'd guess not since it's about teaching his daughter who is d/Deaf, not deafblind, and tactile sign isn't in much use outside of the deafblind community. d/Deaf and blind people don't use it much, I believe.
Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by adinisom on Saturday November 16, 2024 @12:35AM
(#42154586)
They can definitely be distinct languages as is the case with protactile. For the deaf-blind people I've met, ASL is their first language and protactile is more of a second. Maybe it's different in other areas of the world.
What I've noticed is that in deaf-blind contexts plain ASL is terrible for back-channeling information... is the listener paying attention? Agreeing? Disagreeing? Laughing? Protactile communicates these back to the signer using touch, and not touching is considered rude.
Re:I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds
by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Friday November 15, 2024 @10:58AM
(#42148050)
That is so painful to hear. Having those two disabilities at the same time cut you out of so much of the world