Re:Francois Chollet is leaving Google
by robertlagrant on Thursday November 14, 2024 @08:55AM
(#42136146)
I agree with all of that.
I think the main differences between private sector bureacracy and public sector bureaucracy are:
- I'm forced to fund the public sector bureaucracy
- There's no competitive pressure putting a lid on public sector bureaucracy
Re:Francois Chollet is leaving Google
by mainecoder on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:35PM
(#42139515)
There is a competitive pressure on public center bureaucracy it is the competition for resources between countries sometimes it is was sometimes it is not but ultimately the public sector will be punished from the outside.
Re:Francois Chollet is leaving Google
by robertlagrant on Friday November 15, 2024 @05:15AM
(#42145516)
Eventually, but tax systems are usually very efficient, and feel the pain a lot later.
There is some competitive pressure with pro-business politicians wanting things to be better, but unless you're in the team seeing the problems I think they struggle to spot what could actually be improved.
I'd say that large bureaucracies are endemic to the public sector in large part because they can't use efficient price or profit mechanisms.
A firm doesn't typically operate like a market internally, but instead it operates like a command economy. Orders flow from the top to be implemented at lower levels, feedback goes the other way, and divisions should generally be more collaborative than competitive.
Bureaucracy manages that command economy, and some amount of it is inevitable. However, inevitability does not mean infallibility, and bureaucracies in general are prone to process orientation, empire-building, and status-based backstabbing.
> ranging from the mental health of employees
Nitpick: I think that disregard of employee mental health is bad, but I don't think it's an unpriced externality. Employees are aware of their own mental health and can factor it into their internal compensation/quality-of-life tradeoff, staying in the job only when the salary covers the stress.